How do you structure your presentation so that jurors can follow it?
In part two of our series on working memory and case presentation, we focus on making the story easier to remember, reducing confusion, and using visuals that support persuasion instead of competing with it.
We look at three practical techniques lawyers can apply immediately: chunking their information together, sequencing, and the three-second rule for visuals.
Capture your jurors’ attention and keep them with you from start to finish, leaving them with just enough mental energy to understand and grasp your argument. It’s better for them, but it also makes your work more focused and efficient too!
If you want more trial prep strategies just like this, but in more depth and delivered straight to your inbox, grab my email newsletter I send out each month:
How jurors (like all people) are built for stories, and a case needs recognizable story elements like a problem, victor, villain, struggle, and resolution.
Instead of piling on five to seven lead-ups, choose the three or four strongest points and leave the rest out.
The brain naturally wants events in order. Disorganized storytelling increases mental strain and weakens memory.
If a visual requires jurors to focus on a specific area, highlight or direct attention to it. If that takes too much work, consider a different visual.
You can also watch today’s episode on my YouTube Channel:
Why do jurors lose track of a trial presentation even when the evidence is strong?
In part one of this two-part series, we look at how attention deficits, mental fatigue, and working memory shape what jurors can absorb.
We find practical ways to reduce cognitive friction in openings, direct examinations, and cross-examinations. And we discuss the idea of a juror’s limited cognitive budget, how to build in cognitive breaks, and a simple 20-minute rule for pacing testimony and presentations.
The goal: make complex material easier to follow, so jurors can stay with the story and make a better connection with you.
And stay tuned for part two, where we’ll focus on structuring presentations that are designed for short-term memory.
Have a trial or mediation coming up and want to test with a focus group? Book a free consultation call with Elizabeth to learn more:
Don’t miss out on the Trial Lawyer Prep Newsletter that is delivered right to your email with extra tips and ‘how to’ information. Join the newsletter here:
Make your next focus group actually reveal the weaknesses, blind spots, and sticky points in your case, before the defense does!
Long, compound questions will kill the conversation.
Keep the flow moving with shorter prompts.
Silence is one of the most useful tools you have when you want honest reactions instead of rehearsed answers.
These are just some of the detailed tips we cover in today’s episode, which helps you make the most of a focus group to get accurate, realistic data and feedback.
The greatest strength of focus groups is their ability to reveal real weaknesses, not just reinforce what you already believe.
So give your groups the tools to deliver what you need, and remember: set aside that lawyer’s instinct to advocate and instead, just listen.
Focus groups can change how you build a case, and build a case frame. Book a free call with me and learn more about my online focus groups for plaintiff personal injury lawyers:
Don’t miss out on the Trial Lawyer Prep Newsletter that is delivered right to your email with extra tips and ‘how to’ information. Join the newsletter here:
How does a small law firm evaluate whether to conduct a focus group?
The expense, the planning and organization, the time it takes: the stakes feel higher when you have a more nimble organization.
Vishal Shah is a plaintiff-side employment lawyer in Boston, MA, who left big law to open his own boutique firm in 2023. He thus knows first-hand the importance of balancing the bottom line and making smart choices for how his firm operates.
And he’s here to tell you: you rarely get a better bang for your buck than through a focus group. Because it’s not just about the value to that particular case, but the strategies, language, vocabulary, and human insight that can be applied to future cases and situations.
The feedback from focus groups helps Vishal and his team spot hidden assumptions, shape depositions, and improve mediation strategy.
Best of all, Vishal walks us through his own process of running a focus group from start to finish: the logistics, planning, advertizing, expenses and implementation.
If you’ve been on the fence about whether a focus groups are worthwhile, today’s conversation presents a very compelling case.
Are you ready to learn more about how focus groups can improve your firm’s efficiency and case presentation? Book a free consultation through the link below:
Don’t miss out on the Trial Lawyer Prep Newsletter that is delivered right to your email with extra tips and ‘how to’ information. Join the newsletter here:
Welcome to Trial Lawyer Prep, where you learn how to better connect with clients and juries, gather strategies for persuasion, and learn how to use focus groups in the process. I’m your host, Elizabeth Larick, and in this episode, we will talk with Vishal Shah. He’s a solo practitioner now, but he used to work for one of the largest big law firms in high-profile litigation. He learned along the way preparation, strategy, and hard work.
His approach comes from his background, his parents who came to the United States in the 1970s, who lived in several different states starting a motel business in southeast Alabama. Vishal learned at an early age the importance of hard work and education, which took him all the way through law school and starting his own firm in 2023. I hope you enjoy this conversation between Vishal and I about focus groups. Let’s dive in.
Hello and welcome to the podcast. I’m your host, Elizabeth Larick, and we have our guest today, Vishal Shah, who’s joining us. Hello and welcome to the podcast.
Vishal Shah (01:10.028)
Hi, Elizabeth. Thank you for having me. Really looking forward to the conversation today.
Elizabeth Larrick (01:15.118)
Absolutely. I was so excited when we met at the Mark Lanier Trial Academy, which I’m sure we could spend the entire episode talking about how amazing that was, but I’m so glad that we met. And when you were like, hey, focus groups are awesome, I was like, of course, we need you to come on the podcast and tell us about how you’re using them, what you’re doing, what got you into it. Because I always love having people come in and give us their kind of
real life experience with focus groups. Obviously I love them, use them every day. So it was exciting to have you come on. So tell us a little bit about kind of your background and how you got into focus groups. And also be sure and tell us, you know, I know we’ve heard a little bit about you in our intro, but don’t don’t hesitate to tell us a little bit more about your background.
Vishal Shah (01:59.818)
Okay. Yeah, absolutely. And thank you again. So, like Elizabeth said, my name is Vishal Shah. I’m a plaintiff’s side employment lawyer, and I’ve been doing that for the past three years or so. I opened my own firm three years ago in July 2023. Before that, I was in big law for about 10 years. I started out doing general commercial litigation work and then switched practice areas to focus more on employment litigation. And at the time, the firm I was at.
Companies didn’t hire our firm unless it was a big ticket case. And there we’re talking about class and collective actions, but also single plaintiff cases where the stakes were really high for the company. And when you’re thinking about high stakes, it’s not just money that you’re thinking about. It could be high stakes from a reputational perspective, or it may have impacts on the business that are larger than just that one case. And so we’re really, really focused on.
big cases, big teams, and litigating those cases that way. Fast forward, now my plaintiff side employment practice is completely different. We are an extremely small practice. We only have a handful of cases. We’re talking about eight to twelve matters ongoing at any time. And those are cases that we’ve strategically picked because the calculus on the plaintiff side is much different than the calculus on the management side.
We have a thorough investigation on the front end. Focus groups are often a part of that, depending on the situation. And then we really just work up the cases that we have in our in our selection group. And I think when we’re talking about focus groups, the dichotomy between the big law approach to it versus the plaintiff side, smaller practice approach is completely different. So focus groups, at least in my experience, and we
It was a trial focused practice. I worked with a lot of partners who tried the cases for the firm, or at least for the employment group across the country. Focus groups were kind of an afterthought. We thought about doing a focus group only after we knew we had a decision on summary judgment when we thought that trial was upcoming. And at that point, it made sense to spend the many, many thousands of dollars to hire a big name company.
Vishal Shah (04:25.154)
To do a full, fulsome, you know, one to two day either mock jury exercise or a clopening, what closing opening together, which they call a clopening. Yeah. Yeah. Or to do that. And so that’s the only way that I thought was to do focus groups when I branched out on my own. And Elizabeth was being very gracious in her opening. It wasn’t that.
We were just talking about focus groups. I came up in FameGirl to Elizabeth basically saying, I love your stuff. Thank you so much for sharing it. It’s helped me a ton. And so when I started the plaintiff side work, I found Elizabeth. I found a couple of other folks who really do great work in this space and have put out a lot of great material for people like me to learn how to do focus groups. And now we use them at every stage of the case.
Elizabeth Larrick (05:17.612)
And that makes me so excited because I love hearing, and that was what made me so intrigued about your story was, you know, that background of like, okay, we’re going to trial. Now we’ve got to run these, you know, huge, massive panels and all these long days. And and it’s just like there’s such different ways of doing it. So super excited then to have you come tell us a little bit about the switchover and like how, you know, it’s kind of opened up your practice.
And again, I love that you were being so selective. I think that makes for a better experience for everybody. Lawyer wise, you know, everybody elsewhise, it makes it easier to manage and and I think do a better job as a lawyer too. So tell me a little bit about like, you know, that transition and also like how you’re using focus groups now.
Vishal Shah (06:06.476)
Yeah, absolutely. So I think when you do a focus group after discovery has closed and after you have a decision on summary judgment, there’s very limited utility in terms of what you can do to to change the facts of your case or not change them, but at least frame them correctly. Because it’s all a framing exercise, in my view. So when you’re doing it, when you’re getting close to trial, there’s
The dis the depositions are done, the written discovery is complete, you have all the documents that you need, and you’re really limited in how you can maneuver in the path that you can go down with respect to the facts that you have. On the flip side, with the plaintiff’s practice, if you’re doing focus groups the way that we do them and the way that many other firms across the country do them, we’re doing focus groups before we decide to accept the case. We do it before a complaint is filed.
We do it before discovery even starts. And then we’ll do it at strategic points depending on what’s needed for that specific matter. At least in my world, the same may or may not be true on the PI side, but the cases that we’re trying are not slam dunks. They do have warts on them. And the the ability to identify the warts.
But then also understand why it’s important in the case and how you can explain how it fits into your own theory is extremely, extremely important.
Elizabeth Larrick (07:38.862)
Absolutely. And of course, totally agree. And I love the idea, you know, what I always think of it as if we’re waiting until, you know, right before trial or that last failed mediation. So, you know, I know in employment law it’s like, did we cross the summary judgment border? And then, you know, okay, whoo, you know, and for personal injury, typically it’s that last mediation. But it’s almost like at that point you just have to figure out how to move things around because you can’t really ad add things. But when you do it early, like you’re saying.
One, you’re you’re getting attitudes, you’re understanding what could be missing, and then you can actually go like find those things or find those witnesses or understand a little bit better about how to kind of get that testimony organized so that you’re not kind of stuck. And again, there are a lot of people who, you know, you may you may just be, you know, like you said, we don’t always get to try our favorite cases. Sometimes we just have to try the ones that won’t settle.
and so in that case it’s like, Okay, how can we make the best case possible? And focus groups can help you do that at the end, but my gosh, the the light and the fun is so much better if you start to in the beginning because then you have so much more places to explore and discovery.
Vishal Shah (08:48.982)
Yeah, absolutely. And I think for us on the plaintiff side, a lot of times when we’re evaluating a case, it’s based certainly on the law, the facts, how the witness presents, the defendants, et cetera. But oftentimes we’re making assumptions throughout that process about what we think will be important to a jury in X County versus a jury in Y County, you know, when we’re deciding what venue to file in. The assumptions that we make.
Are often based on our own experience and life choices and what’s important to us and how we dictate those assumptions throughout the case. But the thing that I love about a focus group is that it tests the buried assumptions that you take for granted. You may have a disability discrimination case on your books, and the employer is supposed to engage in what’s called a reasonable.
accommodation dialogue and interactive dialogue is what it’s called for a reasonable accommodation. And we know these things like the back of our hand. It’s the same as many concepts in the PI world for PI lawyers. But I did a focus group maybe three, three months ago where we were talking through these issues and one of the participants raised her hand and said, Well, isn’t she employed? Isn’t the plaintiff employed at will?
And doesn’t that just make it okay for the company to to terminate her, even if she needs these accommodations? And so it caused me to take a step back and and deal with the at-will doctrine, which is you can be fired for for any reason at any time as long as it’s not a discriminatory or illegal reason. And so now in the depositions that we’re taking, we are asking questions about the at-will rule and getting
the company’s representatives to testify that, yeah, we can fire you and hire you for any reason. We just can’t discriminate against you for the fact that you asked for an accommodation. And when they hear it, when the jury hears it from the mouth of the corporate representative or the HR person or the manager, it’s just much more powerful. But I we would never have crossed that boundary if we hadn’t done a focus group.
Elizabeth Larrick (11:14.966)
my gosh, yes. I mean the hidden assumptions are everywhere. I think and and we, you know, again, you get into the the rhythm of what you are doing and what you’re thinking and and then sometimes that’s the best thing, even if you’re doing a short, you know, even a one hour focus group can give you these little hidden assumptions that people are having or attitudes, you know. I mean, it it never ceases to amaze me where we think that there’s not a negative attitude about a fact or
you know, we have this a completely different assumption or attitude about it. And then like they they come in and just like blow it out of the water. So it’s always right super fascinating to hear it. And then what I love as well is I’m sure you probably have this experience where you may want to test that attitude. Like, okay, I’m hearing this attitude, but like is this based on your personal experience or just a general attitude everybody else has? And so when you kind of like push up against it in a you know kind of a neutral way or just conversational way.
It expands it even better for you to feel, okay, like I see this negative attitude, but here’s where it’s coming from. And so a good example is we just had a focus group last week. It was very negative, like very critical group. And what we could see after the fact is it wasn’t one person like leading the negative train. It was like all these separate ideas and backgrounds and life experiences that brought every
you know, mostly everybody the same conclusion, but it was like, okay, this is so helpful because it’s not like someone just took charge and took over the focus group and everybody agreed. They had such great ideas, like all separate little ideas. And I’m like, okay, these are all little things now that we need to cover and tackle. And, you know, whether it’s in depositions or just thinking, keep it under your hat for void dire. So have you ever had that situation where you have like a lot of negative feedback, but it’s all
individually from a different perspective.
Vishal Shah (13:14.188)
I’ve never personally had that situation come up. Well, I I I take that back. Th it has come up in some focus groups where people think that the company ha hasn’t done anything wrong. And they have a lot of reasons for why the company’s actions were legitimate. And so, you know, the Atwill rule that I mentioned earlier, or the company’s policy, or
There’s no other employees who have faced this same type of discipline or accommodation issue before. And so you start to understand how the defense’s arguments will play. And for me, the most important thing is, okay, I understand that now. Let me get out ahead of it and address it and frame it in the appropriate way so that when they hear Mr. Defense lawyer or Mrs. Defense Lawyer get up and give their spiel.
They’ve already heard it from me and have already heard why it doesn’t move the needle or why it’s not important in this particular case.
Elizabeth Larrick (14:18.594)
Yeah, absolutely. And what I love too is like you’re hearing, even if the defense doesn’t get that right, like they may get up and give you a different theory. You you know what’s already in their mind. So it’s like, okay, I I’m gonna tackle what you’re what I hear from defense, but I also know I have to tackle this other thing that’s just they’re just thinking it. It’s so helpful to know like what you’re up against. It’s kinda what I always tell people, like you think it’s just one risk, but I mean you I mean everybody
has different life experiences and you’re not you know, you gotta just test some of the stuff to make sure you’re not, you know, missing that additional risk or assumption that could be completely wrong.
Vishal Shah (14:55.82)
And I think jurors attitudes have changed even over the past six, seven, eight years. I mean, we see it in the focus groups that we’re doing now. There is more anti-corporate sentiment. People don’t believe big companies. If there’s a sloppy procedure that a big company has done, well, it raises eyebrows because it’s you’re a multi-billion dollar company. What do you mean you didn’t follow the all your own policy?
on this issue. And I think when you can understand kind of the trend generally and where the country is going, it kind of helps when you’re dealing with that very micro focused group as well, when you’re dealing with the specific issues of your case.
Elizabeth Larrick (15:41.122)
Absolutely. And I that was one of my questions I was gonna have is what trends are you seeing? And that’s one of the things that I’ve seen is yeah, generally there’s a lot of distrust going on. whereas before not necessarily you had like full trust, but it w the you know, they leaned a little bit more to giving more credibility to the other side. So what other things are you have you been seeing in your focus groups?
Vishal Shah (16:05.71)
I think certainly the anti-corporate sentiment is one. I think number two, I think oftentimes we’re also looking at evaluation for the case. Where do people, normal people, think the exposure is going to be or where are they going to give a verdict? And I think the numbers that I was seeing at the beginning of my career versus a beginning of my plaintiff’s side career versus the numbers I’m seeing past couple of weeks.
They’re higher because people are just angrier and they’re less believing of corporations as a whole. I think that’s sad for the country, but it’s also very helpful for plaintiff’s eye practices because you know oftentimes it’s the David and the Goliath, right? David is trying to expose the corporate wrongdoing. And when we can show jurors what has happened in our specific case.
I think that sentiment kind of helps that people can understand it a lot better as opposed to just saying, no, Tom’s general store down the road could never do something like this. I know Tom. Well, it’s not Tom’s general store anymore, it’s insert big box pharmacy.
Elizabeth Larrick (17:18.73)
Right, right. And I I also I think that there’s just been we is thinking about the numbers, right? Like the values of the numbers. I think there’s like just in general, the exposure that we have now to how much money companies are making. I’m seeing generally people are like it’s kind of a weird divide because I see it where
People are putting more more dollars in the bank, right? More, more in the evaluation. But then there are other people that I see where because we are in such a weird place of economically like speaking, like people are having to make hard choices about like what they buy at the grocery store and like gas and stuff like that. So there’s this weird kind of dichotomy where I’m seeing some people are just holding on. Like, well, they don’t need more than that. I mean, ’cause it’s
There’s still always this underlying thing of like I don’t wanna give somebody like more than they need kind of a weird ’cause I don’t have more than what I need. So it’s it’s just it’s it’s such a weird thing that I’m kind of seeing here and there with some of our focus groups.
Vishal Shah (18:23.27)
That’s such an interesting point that you make. It feels it still feels like this. It feels like whenever a jury is making an award of money damages, it’s almost like it’s out of their own pocket as opposed to from the company’s pocket. And so they’re very meticulous, at least my in my experience, they’re very meticulous in how they come up with the numbers and how they justify what they write down on the verdict form.
I’ll tell you a funny story that just happened a couple of weeks ago. a friend of mine, another lawyer in Massachusetts, PI lawyer, won a massive verdict, fifty-six, fifty-seven million dollars in a in a single plaintiff case. And the facts were, as you would expect with a verdict of that size, really sad, catastrophic facts where a person’s life has been changed forever. And not only that person’s, but their entire families.
And so I was just having breakfast with my parents, and my parents are in their 70s. They’re immigrants from India who moved here in the 70s. So they’ve been here for 50 plus years and you know, have have lived in America that entire time. And I was just telling my parents about what had happened in this lawsuit and about the verdict as a whole. And the first thing that my own mother said, as a plaintiff’s lawyer’s mother, was
my God, they should have some kind of caps on these kinds of damages. And once I kind of got past the shock of my own mother saying that, I well, I I took a step back and I said, Well, mom, you know, here’s what happened to this man. And, you know, he’s lost use of his legs, he’s older, so he’s not gonna be able to work anymore. And this is all the care that he’s gonna need for twenty-four hours for the next
10, 15, 20 years, started going through all of these specifics about why a verdict could be that big. And and then I asked her the question we would never ask a juror, right? The golden rule question. It’s like, well, well, if it god forbid it doesn’t happen in our family, but if it happened to somebody you know knew, what would you say then? And then she said, Well, they should deserve every single dollar that they need to at least place them
Vishal Shah (20:44.68)
in as comfortable as a position as they would have been if not for this accident. And so dealing with these sort of mindsets in terms of identifying them, identifying them and then working through them.
Elizabeth Larrick (21:00.106)
Yeah, yeah. And I think it is sometimes a little bit, you know, not like older durs for like there’s definitely still generational effects of that, like it’s coming out of my, you know, my pocket versus, you know. So I I I always think it’s so fascinating to hear like those stories. And I’ve had plenty of, you know, non-lawyer friends and they see the billboard with like, you know, and I say
But do you know what’s on the other side of that? Like when you see that billboard, you see dollars, but what you don’t see is what somebody had to s go through to get on the other side. You know, so it’s like, okay. So it’s it’s so fascinating how like those little things and that’s why like when we talk about voudir, it’s like, you gotta talk about money because people have such strong opinions and like you know, taking some of those opinions back in the verdict room, like can really
like not necessarily get you a zero, but really stunt some of the things that are going on. So I think it’s always so fascinating when we see the numbers, but then have these conversations in focus groups to hear what people are worried about, like when it comes to giving more, you know, money or whatever it may be in their minds. But seeing the numbers is I think is helpful. It is sometimes a little bit like, you know, okay, well it’s focus group, whatever.
But it’s what goes behind those numbers I think is always so fascinating w when we hear what people have to say about it.
Vishal Shah (22:27.232)
Right. And y look, I think there’s a l a lot of great lawyers across the country that have written so much wonderful material on how to frame damages and how to have those discussions. I think many of these books are right behind me on those very issues. And I think saying it early and often to to get jurors comfortable with the dollar figures that you’re ultimately going to be asking for is really important. And if it is a sticking point, I wanna know that when I can do something about it, as opposed to
No, much later when I can’t do much.
Elizabeth Larrick (22:59.2)
Right, right. And that I mean, that’s sometimes where we focus group just someone’s gonna ask for this amount of money, you know, it’s like okay, whoa, wait y you know, here’s what I need to see, kind of a thing, ’cause some people are always gonna have sticker shock, you know, when it comes to some of the numbers. But yeah, there’s definitely wonderful books out there about talking about it. And I know that some people still feel like, I don’t want to talk about it in one year and you know, it’s like, well, you know, let’s if you are doing the work with focus groups early.
You’re getting a new mindset about, okay, it’s not necessarily I need to do this for the case. I n I’m hearing all these things outside of my normal mindset, like I need to ask different questions to find out and make sure I’m I’m tagging all these little things that are not in my mind but in the juror’s mind.
Vishal Shah (23:49.004)
Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. I think this is a little bit different than what we were just talking about, but one of the other things that I really like focus groups for are just to listen to the participants whenever they’re explaining what their view of something is. Because oftentimes if you’re listening close enough, they will give you a theme or a if the grab doesn’t fit, you must equit type of phrase that you can use.
Both if you’ve done it early enough in your depositions to get the testimony in, and then obviously in your opening cross or close and or close at trial. That’s the only other piece that I forgot to mention earlier, which I think is great.
Elizabeth Larrick (24:33.294)
Absolutely. I mean, I call it our word bank, right? Like when we come into a and I let like lots of employment is a great place for analogies and metaphors. Medical cases are also super great. But even things that are kind of like a little highly technical, like I love how they just simplify things quickly, like so fast. Versus we could spend all day trying, okay, how do we make you know, go to Chat GPT and what are analogies for this situation? You know, but
Getting it from focus groups is just so much better. And then how they talk about it in the word bank and like it it’s so helpful when we get to sit down and like, okay, I’m gonna write my voidier, I’m gonna write my opening statement. And it’s having those phrases in there makes it so much more appealing to their brains, like they’re hearing things that are like but also you’re you’re just speaking to them like it’s like magic when you can read their minds. So it’s another fabulous takeaway for for focus groups.
Well tell us a little bit. Do you have a recent success or a fun focus group story you could share with us?
Vishal Shah (25:33.836)
Yeah. So, you know, I think oftentimes the benefits of a focus group are certainly the ones that we’ve been talking about, right? How to frame evidence and how to understand what can be a challenge in your case versus what’s not a challenge. Just helping you tell a clear story overall. I had a very tough age discrimination case, maybe two months ago. And we were set to go to me mediation two months ago and
And one of the issues that we were running into that I find very difficult in age discrimination cases all across the board is that it’s, at least in my experience, the most permissible type of discrimination. People don’t really put up with race or national origin or religious discrimination too much. Same thing with gender. But I think age discrimination doesn’t strike
People the same way as these other types. And so trying to think about how a jury is going to react to that was really important in my case. But the thing I kept hearing from the other side is this isn’t age discrimination. This isn’t age discrimination. This isn’t age discrimination. We don’t think it’s age discrimination because these gentlemen were struggling with their job or you know, what insert whatever reason they had. And
I just took their email, wrote down the five or six issues why they said this wasn’t age discrimination, and then convened a focus group, which is awesome and incredibly easy to do. And we could talk about that as well, Elizabeth. But I think convening a focus group and then working through those issues with the focus group and videoing it. So you have.
Someone asking about this very particular reason that the insurance company and defendants gave and how that plays into age discrimination. And you hear the participants say, no, of course not. That doesn’t make any sense. And here’s why. And you have five or six of these little snippets. And so when I go in and do the opening at mediation, which I used to not ever do.
Vishal Shah (27:52.258)
But then I attended a seminar, actually, one of Mark Lanier’s settlement academies. I switched my approach and do an opening statement out. And in that opening statement, I addressed those particular issues and I played the clips at mediation. And the adjuster saw it, the company’s lawyer saw it, the company saw it, and we settled that case later that day. And I don’t think we would have gotten there if we didn’t have.
the other side hearing from normal people what their reaction was to this evidence. And look, there’s a fine line. You can’t be overtly advocating for your own position. It needs to be a little flat and maybe even favor the defense a good bit. So then they can’t nitpick at your process.
Elizabeth Larrick (28:39.51)
Yeah, absolutely. I mean, I love people using clips and mediation. I mean, when I practiced, that’s one hundred percent what I did. I didn’t always do it in the correct fashion, but in the you know, because you get excited, you get these amazing clips and it’s like, I can’t say it any better than the what they just said. And I did not tell them to say that. So I love that you are using clips at mediation and I love, you know, I think, you know, Mark Lanier’s Settlement Academy is also super helpful.
I mean, you could probably tell us a bit more about that as well. but yeah, I think clips and mediation are awesome. It can help open their minds because you know from your personal experience, they’re not doing focus groups. I mean, I know for my personal they’re not doing like focus groups until the very end. So they’re not really considering at all what the jury is thinking until very end.
Vishal Shah (29:29.462)
Yeah. They’re just not doing focus groups in big law. at least my experience, many folks are not doing them until after summary judgment. And oftentimes discussions that they’re having about cases are with the team that they have and the client, and that’s about it. I mean, you’re not getting the fresh perspective that you otherwise would.
Elizabeth Larrick (29:51.118)
Absolutely, absolutely. And you know, you get stuck in your own loop pretty much. Yes. that’s why it’s so a nice. So tell me a little bit about you talked about like how easy it is to convene one. So a lot of people when I talk about focus groups, they’re they’re so expensive and I don’t have time for that. And like I’d have to convince the client for the expense. So tell me a little bit about, you know, how you have kind of worked this into you’ve got a smaller firm, you’re probably thinking always about expenses and costs, you know.
So tell me how you’ve been able to kind of work these in in a way that is efficient, but not like overly burdensome on your case expenses.
Vishal Shah (30:26.818)
Yeah. So once I learned that focus groups were a thing before summary judgment, I went down the rabbit trail and started reading books about them, watching videos through so many different providers, finding people like yourself who are doing this kind of work and have a lot of material out there for folks to use and grow. So I read up on everything that I could read up on.
And then I spoke to some other individuals who are doing focus groups on the employment side and even on the PI side, the way that they do them, and just kind of learn from them. And so I just put together a checklist of all the things that I wanted to not substantively accomplish, but all the nitty-gritty logistical, technical things that I needed, right? When are we gonna post? Where are we gonna post? How are we gonna filter out?
the scammers. How are we going to test? Are we going to do it in person? Are we going to do it in video? And just right now, it’s a pretty easy process. So I’ll walk through it real quick. We decide a date and time that we’re going to do the focus group whenever I’m available. And I usually don’t have the clients join. So it’s really just on my own schedule. And I’ll pick a Thursday or Tuesday, not to interfere with you know people’s lives.
Most of the time, and we’ll do it for three or four hours. And you can go on Craigslist and you put up an ad that says, you know, mock jurors wanted. If you just go to Craigslist right now, you can find somebody looking for a focus group participant and you can kind of crib off of their own ad, or at least you know what info to include. You pick the time, you pick the place you I pay for a particular survey program that people can input their responses in, and then it’ll it will tell me.
you know, IP addresses. So I know if there’s somebody from Africa or India filling out the survey, well, you guys aren’t in this Massachusetts County. I don’t need you in this participant group. I’m sure you have great things to say, but I need people who live here to tell me what they think about it. And then once you kind of have called your collective, then you just I the way that I like to do them is I like to have a 60 40 split.
Vishal Shah (32:48.042)
I like the case facts that are presented to be 60% in favor of the defense or the employer. I don’t need to hear that my case is great. I need to hear what’s bad about my case or what’s problematic or what’s causing concern to jurors about my own case. And so I skew it that way and often don’t include my best facts. And then we’ll just do the type of focus group that we want to do. Either we’re testing issues.
We’re testing specific pieces of evidence. I might want to just know what people feel about my plaintiff. So I may put up her des deposition testimony, probably some of the strongest parts for the management side, and let people react to that just so I can understand more about how this person is portraying. Because the goal for us in every case is for every witness on our end to be authentic.
Who whoever they are and wherever they came from, I don’t want them to put on airs or act like they are somebody that they’re not, because jurors are smart. They can read through that and people can tell when you’re putting on an act. And so I think that’s really important. And then after we have them fill out a survey, and only then do we send them the money to to complete the whole process. But that that’s in a nutshell how it goes.
Elizabeth Larrick (34:10.688)
Yeah. Awesome. That’s fantastic. Yeah, I think that’s it’s so helpful. And it it sounds like maybe you’re running more than one case in a focus group. Does that sound about right? Or
Vishal Shah (34:19.342)
Typically it’s just one case. Yeah. It’s just one case. And then if I need to do another one for another case, because it may be in a different county, I want to make sure that they have the right facts and try not to overload a lot of things because I think the best part of a focus group is listening. And if you have a lot of things to go through, you’re kind of running through a bullet form list as opposed to taking a break and listening and even diving a little deeper.
Elizabeth Larrick (34:21.356)
Just one case. Okay.
Vishal Shah (34:49.206)
Kind of like you would do in jury selection, diving deeper into particular issues, right? Miss Larick, you said that ex bot you know, this would prevent you from giving a big verdict. Who else feels this way like Miss Lairic? And have people raise their hand and try to figure out what the touch points are for different people.
Elizabeth Larrick (35:07.404)
Yeah, I mean that’s why I love having basically a lot of they’re just very conversational, you know. But you know, people always ask, Well, are they deliberating? I’m like, No, like they’re not. Like we’re we’re having live conversations and like it’s it’s a guided conversation, if you will. So make sure we’re not like falling off cliffs that like don’t help anyone. Yes. but yeah, it’s those little conversations. did anybody else have that thought too? Like
You know, where it’s like, super conversational. It’s very easy for people to join in. It’s very easy for people to say, you know, I didn’t think that at all. And here’s what I was thinking though. You know, that I think is like fostering a good conversation with people. So it feels like it is very neutral. We are literally just wanting to get your opinion. I’m not here to win anything. Yeah. Is always like the most helpful way to moderate.
Vishal Shah (35:54.892)
Yeah, I agree. It people are more willing to give you their true reaction to certain things if they don’t feel like you want them to say something in particular. Or if you’re looking for an answer.
Elizabeth Larrick (36:09.816)
Mm-hmm. Yeah. And that can be so hard when you’re first starting out. That’s why I always tell people like, get the books, literally read the question from the page. Don’t try to like rip it because you’ll you’ll riff it in a way that you don’t even realize you’re being one sided. Yes. and so it’s like just stick with the, you know, it’s it’s totally okay. It’s actually even better because I feel like when we try to riff as plaintiff lawyers, like it always skews the on the advocacy side. So
and that’s a good thing, right? That’s why we’re all, you know, that’s why we’re playing this lawyers because we have a hard for advocacy. So awesome. Well, thank you so much for coming on the podcast. Before we go, I always ask, like, is there anything you would say or a word of encouragement to folks who are maybe on the fence about using focus groups earlier in cases?
Vishal Shah (36:54.93)
Yeah. So first of all, thank you for having me. This was a lot of fun to talk about focus groups. In terms of what recommendations I would have to anyone on the fence about a focus group is the Nike slogan. Just do it. It will feel uncomfortable the first time. You’ll feel like it’s a ton of work in addition to the work that you already have. But I promise you, it won’t be perfect the first time. It won’t be perfect the second time. You’ll get better as you do it.
But even more than that, the insights that you get will make you a better lawyer, will make your case stronger, and ultimately get better outcomes for clients, which is why we’re all here. So I hope part of this conversation will encourage folks to do it. And obviously I’m happy to if people can reach out to me and learn whatever I know. I’m a I’m an open book and help in that way.
Elizabeth Larrick (37:46.306)
Fantastic. No, I that’s a great piece of advice because I think sometimes we get stuck in our head about like, this is expensive, like I’m gonna spend all this time, like what am I even gonna get from it? And you nailed it. Like it’s it’s helping you and it’s helping the immediate case, but it helps every case after that because it just opens your mind up to to all the things you weren’t thinking.
Vishal Shah (38:07.544)
And it doesn’t have to be expensive. I mean, if you’re the lawyer conducting the focus group for your own case, certainly it’s your time, but let’s put that off to the side because most of us are contingency-based practices. So whether you’re looking at discovery or whether you’re conducting a focus group, it’s the same thing. So really it’s well, am I paying for a location? If you’re doing it virtually, you can skip that cost. Most of us have a Teams or a Zoom subscription, so that’s great. And Craigslist is free.
So you can pay 10 or so, well, I guess it’s $10 to post an ad on Craigslist. You could pay $10 a month for a survey program. And then if you search in your area, you can get a good sense of how much people are paying for participation for a three or four hour session. It ranges anywhere from 75 bucks to 175 bucks, depending on the cost of living in your area. So if we’re talking eight to ten jurors at $100 a pop.
I mean, it’s really like fifteen hundred dollars on the max maximum end. I mean, that’s kind of nothing for the work that we’re doing and the insights that are on the other side of that.
Elizabeth Larrick (39:18.858)
Right. The value that you gain is exponential. compared to like i you know, it’s it’s apples and pencils, but I would tell people it’s like you you may feel like this is such an expense, but I’m like, the value you can gain from it over and over again, by the way. Like I always tell people, like, it’s not a one and done. Like you go back and every time you revisit that focus group, you’re gonna gain a little bit more insight, a little bit more value before you, you know, go to that next supposition or mediation or whatever it may be. So
Vishal Shah (39:47.158)
And when you record them, you can always look back at the transcript or watch the video. And every time I do that I have some additional insight. And so look, I I could talk about this all day. The the they take a lesson. That’s true.
Elizabeth Larrick (40:00.382)
We both this is true. This is true. Absolutely. Well, thank you so much for joining us. I will definitely put your contact in the show notes if anybody wants to reach out and ask you questions. Other than your website, do you have any LinkedIn or anywhere else people could follow or add you as a friend?
Vishal Shah (40:14.744)
Yes, I’m on LinkedIn. It’s Vishal Shah, employment lawyer out of Boston. There should be the first or second search that comes up. So please add me on LinkedIn. I’m look forward to connecting with everybody and obviously feel free to reach out as well. Thank you, Elizabeth.
Elizabeth Larrick (40:29.164)
Wonderful. Thank you so much for joining us. Thank you all for listening here today, this episode. Let’s talk about setting up a virtual focus group for you. I run several every single month and you can click the link in the show notes for a free consultation.
When you had planned for a five day trial, and then the first morning in the courtroom, the judge announces that the case will be completed in three days. Hard stop. No exceptions.
Is it a scramble and a panic?
Or maybe, could it be a blessing?
In this day and age especially, the last thing we want to do is bore our jurors, throw too much information at them and expect them to keep up. Attention spans are shorter and people are easily distracted, but even when looking at it objectively, can we really expect someone to hear and absorb each and every sentence over the course of multiple days?
Which in turn means, why not plan and strategize around keeping information clear, logical and structured in the first place?
Less is more.
And there is a time and place for more expansive detail, testing out ideas and arguments, and gauging the impact of your words: focus groups.
That’s what I bring to a trial consult. It’s not just running a focus group specific to your case, it’s pairing it with everything else I’ve learned across more than a thousand focus groups:
Patterns and how jurors think
What they trust
What they dismiss
What are the attitudes they’re bringing to your case
I help you craft the strongest case possible with the strongest presentation. If you have an upcoming trial, use the link below to schedule a free consultation!
Don’t miss out on the Trial Lawyer Prep Newsletter that is delivered right to your email with extra tips and ‘how to’ information. Join the newsletter here:
If you are headed to trial, this episode shows why the judge’s trial rules, schedule, and persona matter more than simply memorizing jury instructions.
I talk about how a trial consultation exposed major surprises in a judge’s courtroom procedures, including half-day sessions, skipped Fridays, limited jury-selection time, and strict expectations that could completely reshape the order of proof, witness strategy, and expert costs.
This episode previously aired on the podcast in 2024, and I’m bringing it back today because it’s the perfect refresher ahead of an upcoming episode where I’ll walk you through a recent trial consult of mine and the verdict. So keep that one in mind, and you can always refer back here for more context!
If you want more trial prep strategies just like this, but in more depth and delivered straight to your inbox, grab my email newsletter that I send out each month:
In our last episode, we learned about Michelle Gessner’s recent trial in North Carolina, where she was forced to pivot from a regular audio/video presentation, using modern technology, to a courtroom with no microphones, no TVs, no projectors and a single power outlet (already claimed by the clerk and the court reporter!).
Michelle used AI to help adapt to this unexpected turn of events, asking it how to craft a visual presentation under these unique circumstances.
Today, we learn how it unfolded.
You could feel the courtroom change as the case progressed, and this was a quick trial: starting on a Monday, verdict by the end of day Tuesday. Literally two days.
In fact, there were some assets to the old-school, analogue approach: better eye contact with jurors, fewer distractions, and more movement.
Using what was learned from the focus groups before the trial, and the creative AI suggestions for presenting evidence, Michelle was able to correctly anticipate the jury’s emotional reactions as the witnesses unfolded.
With AI helping between trial days to make sure she’d met her burden of proof, Michelle then gave her closing argument with foam boards instead of any PowerPoint slides or technology.
And the result: she won.
If you want more trial prep strategies just like this, but in more depth and delivered straight to your inbox, grab my email newsletter that I send out each month:
https://www.larricklawfirm.com/newsletter
In this episode, we cover:
How the visuals created with AI significantly engaged the jury.
Focus groups provided valuable insights for trial strategy.
How word choice is so important in your presentation.
Closing arguments were enhanced by using visuals instead of technology.
Remember to check out Episodes 128 & 129, featuring Michelle Gessner and her $21 million dollar verdict against Wells Fargo:
Michelle Gessner is one of the few lawyers, if not the only lawyer, in North Carolina who has both Big Law and Big Company defense experience, as well as 10 years of employee-side employment litigation experience, which she has been nearly exclusively handling since 2015.
Michelle possesses a deep understanding of the many challenges employees face dealing with wage theft and other illegal employment practices.
Prior to its formation, Michelle gained extensive experience in all legal issues facing the retail, restaurant, and hospitality industries by serving as the Chief Litigation and Employment Law Counsel for publicly traded companies such as Family Dollar Stores, Inc. (FDO), Darden Restaurants, Inc. (DRI), Big Lots Stores, Inc. (BIG) and TriNet (TNET). Michelle also served as the SVP, General Counsel, and Chief Administrative Officer for Ovation Brands, a privately held $1 billion restaurant company.
Follow and Review:
We’d love for you to follow us if you haven’t yet. Click that purple ‘+’ in the top right corner of your Apple Podcasts app. We’d love it even more if you could drop a review or 5-star rating over on Apple Podcasts. Simply select “Ratings and Reviews” and “Write a Review” then a quick line with your favorite part of the episode. It only takes a second and it helps spread the word about the podcast.
Have a trial or mediation coming up and want to test with a focus group? Book a free consultation call with Elizabeth to learn more:
Don’t miss out on the Trial Lawyer Prep Newsletter that is delivered right to your email with extra tips and ‘how to’ information. Join the newsletter here:
Welcome back to Trial Lawyer Prep. I’m your host, Elizabeth Larrick, and this is part two of my conversation with Michelle Gessner about using AI to prepare and win her recent trial. If you haven’t listened to episode 170 yet, pause right now and go grab that first. The link is in the show notes. We covered how Michelle used AI to build her courtroom visuals, how she prepped for a low-tech courthouse.
And how focus groups helped her from the very beginning shape her entire strategy. Today we’re picking up where we left off. Before we jump in, a quick reminder. I send out two emails every month that trial lawyers actually want to read. One is my newsletter with case prep strategies, trial psychology, trial tactics, tips for witness prep, and the other is my focus group trends report.
Real data from real jury research happening right now. Both are free, and the link is in the show notes to join. Alright, let’s talk about what happened when Michelle actually got into the courtroom, how she used AI during trial, what the jurors thought of her visuals, and of course the verdict. Let’s jump right in.
Welcome to Trial Lawyer Prep. I’m your host, Elizabeth Larick, and we are going to continue our fantastic episode with Michelle Gessner talking about using AI during trial and also the outcome of her case, where she used zero technology in the courtroom and was able to get a wonderful return for her client. So, Michelle, welcome back to the podcast.
Michelle Gessner (01:43.384)
Yes. Thank you so much. Thanks for having me.
Elizabeth Larrick (01:45.986)
Fantastic. Let’s jump right in. Okay. If you didn’t catch our first episode, Michelle gave a great billboard about the case that she took to trial in a teeny tiny little courthouse way in the middle of nowhere in North Carolina with no technology. Like seriously, just one outlet in the entire courtroom. Okay. So what episode one would cover, and I really strongly encourage you to go listen to it, is focus groups.
Using AI to prepare visuals and get ideas. And we even tackled the logistics of preparing those visuals against any objection you may get. Now, for this episode, Michelle is going to tell us about how during trial she used AI to get some help. She’s going to tell us about the visuals in the courtroom. How did she know what were jury reactions? Then ultimately the verdict here.
All right, so Michelle, you left us with a cliffhanger on that last episode. So walk us through a little bit about using AI during trial.
Michelle Gessner (02:53.432)
Sure. During trial, I was able to use AI to really be my my checker, if you will, before I closed plaintiff’s case in chief. You know, anybody’s tried a case. You don’t really want to close your case because you want to make sure you’re gonna get past directed verdict. And did I miss anything? You can have as many checklists as you want, notepads as you want, but as the evidence is coming in to be in the moment, you’re not really remembering whether you’ve checked everything off. We’re a small firm.
I had a paralegal and my daughter in the courtroom. That was it. I’m the only person at counsel table. Because there was no technology, we didn’t need a tech person to run any technology. So at the end of day one, I was able to go back to the room and just really check myself before the next day to see is there another witness I need to put on? Did I miss an element that I’m concerned about? Is there something that I left hanging with the jury that I didn’t really quite close that loop? So I was able to really check myself.
related to my trial plan with what I knew came in. The other thing that I was able to do is we did rest the next morning. It was prepare for defenses case in chief. And so we talked about in the first episode a little bit about the cross examination, which was witnesses that I we didn’t know who they were bringing. We knew who they put on their client list or on their witness list, but it was a lot of people. We didn’t know who they were bringing and I had not deposed any of the people that they did bring. And so I was really using
you know, what we already had in and the visuals that we talked about before on how can I use this with each witness. And Elizabeth said in the first episode something important, which is often your client wants you to go tit for tat in cross-examination because sometimes they’re hearing bad things that they’ve never been told before, either to their faces or behind their back. But really staying focused on your case and what you need to prove and taking the high road.
And dealing with your client after the fact, if you choose to do that, has worked well for me at least twice. In two different trials, in the Wells Fargo case and in this case, we had witnesses who got up on the stand and said some really horrible things about the blana. And if I’d gotten low with them in the dirt, it would have taken us completely off track. But staying high and using the visuals, the checklists we talked about, it allowed me to really get a punch with the cross examinations and do it in a really short amount of time. This particular judge
Michelle Gessner (05:16.856)
Told us, you know, it’s gonna go fast. It went really fast. The trial lasted only two days. And I think we put on seven or eight witnesses in one day. And then they put up, I think, five witnesses in one day. And so we had a jury verdict by the end of the day on Tuesday. So it was literally a two-day trial. So again, using AI, and let me walk back for a minute. You said, How did it work? How did the presentation of the phone boards and all that work? So as a recap.
No technology. We had to have I live in Charlotte, North Carolina. We have an office of Wilmington, North Carolina, but we were traveling from Charlotte to Elizabeth City on a Sunday night to try this case starting on a Monday. It was a six hour drive one way. And there’s not a lot of resources in Elizabeth City to get something created there. So we had to have everything ready the week before, including these phone boards. And so I mentioned in episode one, this case initially was very difficult.
In the sense that the plaintiff had had a prior relationship with her boss. She regrets that, but again, the hostile work environment started after the relationship broke off. Our judge initially, even at the pretrial conference, wasn’t really excited about the case and he didn’t hide it. When he gave a statement of the case to the jury, he wasn’t really excited about the fact there was a prior relationship, and you could tell. So my, you know, my back was up a little bit because I’m a little nervous about.
what he’s saying and how he’s saying it. And then I get up for opening statement. And I say this is a, you know, hostile environment, sexual harassment case. And you could see jurors were rolling their eyes. They were like, my God, know, I don’t know if it’s the Me Too or what people were very desensitized to the facts of this case. But what it worked, when I put up the phone boards, the circles we talked about in the first episode with the progressively
bad behavior. By the time the third circle was up, people were sitting up in their seat. When they heard a tracker on her car, beating down her front door, programming her garage door, when they heard the facts, the evidence that was going to come into this case, you could see sort of their attention change. Now I had to prove it, right? We had to prove it. But certainly those visuals in opening statement helped tremendously at least to change their perspective.
Michelle Gessner (07:40.962)
That maybe there’s more to this story. We just need to listen and hear, as opposed to just judging that this is somebody that had a relationship. And so here we go again.
Elizabeth Larrick (07:49.354)
Yeah, nice. Yeah. And I will also say, you know, you you did call the defendant boss in your case in chief. This is still a very big, like, you know, working with other lawyers, like this is still a big contention point and big decision making for people who, you know, there is this. Well, what if they start doing their case in chief in my case? You know, what so walk us through just really quickly about like
Michelle Gessner (07:58.958)
Yes.
Elizabeth Larrick (08:15.702)
that particular witness and why you chose to put him in your case.
Michelle Gessner (08:20.014)
Sure. We didn’t start with him. We started with a disinterested fact witness, somebody who had observed most of this bad behavior and had taken contemporaneous notes at the time and shared it with the government when she filed her ESC charge. So we put her on first to really set the stage. And then we called the owner of the business, the bad actor, as our third witness. And a lot of our burden of proof really needed to come in through him. That’s why we called him. But it also allowed me to prove up
All the things in the circle. In the thr when I say the circles, I’m talking about what I talked about in episode one, which was the progressive circles that we used to show the bad behavior. Again, how did I present it? One foam board at a time. We had them stacked up and I had to rehearse this so they weren’t falling off of the easels while I’m standing up there. So one phone board was the small circle, the next one had the small and the second larger one, the third phone board had the third. So we had I don’t know, I had probably ten foam boards for the entire trial. But
Calling him, my first thing I wanted to do was get out of his mouth an admission that everything that was on those circles he had ag he had admitted happened. He did. He admitted it happened during the depositions. And so of course their defense was, well, it wasn’t quite to the extent to which she’s making it out to be. But he couldn’t deny that he put a tracker on a car. He couldn’t deny that he kicked in the bathroom door, right? He couldn’t deny some of the egregious things. Also, you know, he’s a business owner. And what we learned from focus groups that
If you’re gonna hang a shingle and you’re gonna open your business and you’re gonna affect people’s livelihood, you gotta comply with the law. Small businesses don’t get a pass. Otherwise, don’t open up your business. And so, you know, those were some of the things we knew jurors were gonna potentially be thinking, but we were not able to check it off with any other witness. So the f witness didn’t own the business, she had no control over it. She was a fellow server at the business.
The next witness was the bookkeeper. And again, she was there and she had witnessed, but it wasn’t her business either. And so then the third witness was the owner. And again, most of the case came in through him. He was the longest witness that we had. I put on my witness, my plaintiff, last. And it did shorten their case in chief with him. They did put him back on the stand, so I got to cross examine him again, which is always something I’m surprised the defendants do because I get two bites then, you know, at the witness who we thought.
Michelle Gessner (10:41.132)
makes our case. Yeah. but the checklist I was mentioning in our episode one about the right way, wrong way, and things that you were expected to do as a business owner to make sure you comply with the law, I stood up and just had that in my hand and literally went one by one by one. And as he tried to explain, I just moved on to the next one. And the jury was really, you know, watching his reaction, you know, a little squirming in the seat. And so you could see, you know, the jury there were jurors who were with us.
after the first witness, but then the jurors really were with us after him. You could s feel the courtroom change. I also think the judge wasn’t convinced. And then when he saw the business owner on the stand, you know, again, the judge doesn’t really get a vote in the jury room, but it does help when your story, the evidence and the truth that you’re having come in at trial really allows the court for the first time to see what actually happened as well. So it was really helpful.
Elizabeth Larrick (11:38.328)
Good, good, good, good, awesome. And just a sidebar, just real fast, when they put him back on the stand, did they try to combat your checklist in the direct that they had with him or did they leave it alone?
Michelle Gessner (11:49.806)
That was amazing to me. They left it alone. It did not come back. When they they really hit on we’re a small business, we don’t have a lot of employees. We service, and this is a really important thing. Don’t let me forget for closing. So we service, you know, a small town. Didn’t really get there, but kind of if you give us a big verdict against us, we’re not gonna be able to stay in business type of thing. We employ a lot of people. You know, so that was sort of a double-edged sword for them. They employed about 40 people. And so if we go out of business, we’re not gonna employ those 40 people.
I’ll just jump in. One of the things AI helped me do in closing, and I’m gonna get the words wrong. I’ve got the transcript. I haven’t looked at it, but maybe they scored some points with saying that they serviced EMTs that had fifty percent off for the police and EMTs and the people who make a small community run and who we rely upon. And so
One of the things we had done with him is we was he’s above the law. So again, putting a tracker on somebody’s car, why didn’t the police do anything? Well, they get fifty percent off their meals at Yeah. So we didn’t really use that. I didn’t use that head on cross examining him, but I brought it together in closing. You know, again, why didn’t the police do more? Why didn’t the police protect her? ‘Cause she did go to the police at the time that he was kicking in her house, you know, breaking in her house and putting a a tracker on her car and they didn’t really do anything.
So to answer your question, no, they did not try to counter that. They tried to counter sort of some of the f bad facts that had come out by saying, here’s who we are in this community. And one of the critical things I think is important, and maybe it was unique about this case, is the judge asked all of the jury panel, Do any of you know where Sneeds Ferry, North Carolina is? And the answer was no. Not a single person on our jury had ever been to Sneeds Ferry, did not know where Sneeds Ferry was, had never heard of Sneeds Ferry.
And so we were really arguing a case to a jury who was very disconnected from the community of where these events happened. And so being able to bring that back around to show that these laws apply to everybody, federal laws apply to everybody who lived in the United States, the state law applied to the people in North Carolina. That was part of the parallel track of having to try this case was the evidentiary basis for this case, but also getting this jury to care about what happens in this case as it relates to their community.
Elizabeth Larrick (14:07.894)
Mm-hmm. Yeah. And I’m sure you probably again you talked about this before, which was word choice was so important. This is not about just restaurant workers. This is workers. You know, this is a boss. Being very thoughtful about that, which I know probably significantly again, you know, reaching people where they may be sitting. Because there were a lot of people in the focus group who had never worked in the restaurant business. But then there were people who had
And that really kinda cut against you because they were like, This happens all the time, it’s no big deal, you know, kind of a that’s just part of the culture of of of a restaurant kind of a thing.
Michelle Gessner (14:44.682)
Work in restaurant and even a defense lawyer as a restaurant, it’s true. People get very desensitized to bad behavior in a restaurant. And so you’re right, on a jury profile, we didn’t really want people who had worked in a restaurant before. Because if they did, they were either going to be very polarized. Like this is bad and we wanna stop it or get over it, go get another job. You know, there was no middle ground with restaurant workers as it related to our focus group.
Elizabeth Larrick (15:07.244)
Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So you did a fantastic job telling us how you used AI during, which again, I’m sure you followed all the ethical rules and just used things that were going to be in trial that were going to be public record. And also probably a little bit of the maybe the jury instructions. Again, there’s nothing secretive about that. Okay, so then you talked about what was happening in the courtroom. Let’s bring it home. Tell us about creating the closing and then also delivering and then the verdict.
Michelle Gessner (15:35.054)
Sure. So again, we didn’t know this particular judge did not go through our jury instructions in a charge conference. So we didn’t know exactly which instructions he was going to read. He didn’t tell us. He never told us. He just read what he read. We also didn’t know which verdict form he was going to use because there were competing verdict forms. So my daughter was with me and so we took white paper and we wrote out the verdict form.
And the critical questions that we thought for sure he was going to put on the verdict form. So it was all in handwriting on you know, flip chart page. Because we if I’d printed a phone board and it was completely wrong or there was a directed verdict on something, then I’m scratching it up. So we knew at least that we had survived Rule 50 and we were gonna have the hostile work environment. And we had two wage an hour claims that we also had on the verdict form, but it was all handwritten.
Same thing. We highlighted only the critical jury instructions that we knew that the jury, we wanted the jury to focus on when they got back in the jury room. Those were all handwritten on butcher paper as well. And so in the Western district of North Carolina, the court reads the instructions first, then you get up and give your closing statement. In the Eastern District, and now I tried a case in February of this year in the middle district, they do it the other way around. You give your closing.
Then they read the jury instructions. So I come back thinking the instruct I didn’t know this either. I come back thinking the instructions are going to be read. And I had a few minutes to collect my thoughts before I get up and give my closing. And my daughter was still working on the the pad of paper in the back of the courtroom. And the judge says, The jury’s with the plaintiff for closing. So I have to get up and give my closing argument. But we made it work. You know, in closing, I reused everything that we had used in trial. I reused the tell them.
what’s the evidence is gonna show and then remind them that you proved your case. And it was very it actually was easier to do with the phone boards. I was able to really make eye contact with the jurors. I was able to have movement in the courtroom. And you have to be comfortable with the pregnant pauses because it’s silent and you’re moving around and you’re doing the phone boards. But I was able to get in front of them and talk to them in a way that you really don’t do very well when you’re running the technology in a different courtroom.
Michelle Gessner (17:50.562)
We was short, twenty minutes, maybe twenty-five minutes, and really focused on the evidence that they heard that was on the circles to prove it out, looked at the checklist, talked about the jury instructions that they were going to receive from the court and the verdict form. And then I sat down. The rebuttal, I didn’t have anything for rebuttal. I just kept it very short and really gave the argument just truly a true rebuttal in response to what I heard from defense counsel.
Which again, he gets up and says, This is a domestic case. We should not be in this courtroom. This is two people who are, you know, basically married who are having a dispute. And it was really easy to counter that because of the timing. You know, again, those circles showed the timing and when things started was at the end of the relationship. And using what we learned from the focus groups, no means no. As adults, when I say I don’t want to be in a relationship with you anymore, the expectation is that as adults, you can accept that. So that was part of the thing.
So anyhow, you asked about the verdict. The jury deliberated about three hours. We had one question and we received a a full verdict. We had asked for compensatory damages for emotional distress only. Okay, that’s important. There were no back wages associated in this case. It was emotional distress only, were her compensatory damages, and we had asked for p punitive damages. The jury gave her forty thousand dollars.
Which is about one year’s pay in emotional distress damages. And they gave her sixty thousand dollars, one and a half times of that one year’s pay in punitive damages. And to get punitive damages in a venue where there’s no connection whatsoever to these people, we were very proud of that. Again, very proud of that. That the jury understood that this type of behavior is not acceptable in the workplace. And they spoke loud and clear.
Elizabeth Larrick (19:45.622)
Yes. Well, congratulations. I know that that was one a speed trial. You know, peop people talk about, we gotta do a speed trial. This was a speed trial and literally, you know, writing out the jury instructions. The cliffhanger here is that when the judge did give the jury instructions, he read a completely different set of instructions, y’all. He didn’t even go with what Michelle had or the other side gave. So the jury really understood what was happening. They
understood what their purpose was. And I think that’s a lot to your credit, Michelle, of getting it down on a level, whatever the instruction is, they understood what they needed to do. They didn’t get tripped up on it. So again, congrats to that. I know that this case is on appeal. True.
Michelle Gessner (20:33.742)
Yes, we’ve appealed. So defendants did not appeal. We have appealed because there were some claims. She had wage an hour claims that one partly were denied on summary judgment. And in part the judge decided during trial not he denied. Summary judgment was denied, rule fifty was denied. We tried the wage claims to the jury. And then he chose not to have them on the verdict form and did not read instructions for the wage and hour claims. So we are on appeal. So stay tuned on that. But yes.
Elizabeth Larrick (21:01.61)
Yeah, so but I know that, you know, again, this is not if you were to try the case again, you would do it all different. And again, we all know here where you sit in July of twenty twenty six and in six months AI is gonna be completely different. It’s different in you know, in the next two months. So the the possibilities are endless with now how to redo this if it must be. Well, thank you so much, Michelle, for joining us. Let’s just do a quick recap for folks, which is we talked about using AI during trial, and that would be Michelle again.
Feeding it information, asking it questions, feeling like, okay, I’ve got all the things that I need to get. And then also, how did those visuals that you created with AI or got AI ideas work? They worked like a charm. I also love that you kind of mentioned the ability to have movement in the courtroom, which a lot of people don’t feel comfortable with. And a lot of times judges just really shut down. So I always
put say, you know, if you can push for that. But I know one of the things that you mentioned to me when our in our preparation call for this podcast was you worked really hard practicing with the foam boards because there were so many. All right. Doubling off those things and making it look as fluid as possible. I know that that probably took some extra time out versus just getting ready for cross and those kinds of good things. So and then ultimately knowing through your reactions you had your parallel, you had your daughter there.
Reading things for you as you went along. And then ultimately a successful jury verdict, even though you are you’d completely different jury instructions.
Michelle Gessner (22:38.744)
Totally different perceptions. And to your point, I’ll let this mention this. This judge who has seen thousands of jury trials, he did tell us if you’re sitting in your seat, you’re not trying your case. So he expected movement in the courtroom. Cause I did ask for permission. I was concerned. I didn’t want to get up and get yelled at by the judge. Right. So I asked during pretrial how much movement I could have, considering there was no technology. And so he gave us a lot of examples of really good trial lawyers and
And what stuck with me is if you’re sitting in your seat and you’re not moving, you’re not really trying your case. So that I take that to heart and I think about that when I’m preparing for my next trial.
Elizabeth Larrick (23:15.404)
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Here’s one thing I know about Michelle that I if you take away nothing other than like what I’m about to tell you about Michelle is Michelle is never afraid to ask a judge for clarification. I mean, between the two trials that I have helped her on, she is not afraid to get what do you mean when you say this? And I really encourage people to do that. I mean, again, Michelle is a seasoned, amazing lawyer. She now has lots of trials under her belt, but
Some of these trials are some of the first really big ones and you know, you weren’t afraid to ask questions to get clarification. And I think that that is a huge marker of a very smart lawyer to figure out what can I do and not do before you you know, he says something in front of the jury.
Michelle Gessner (24:00.888)
Well, thank you. Lots of failings to get there, but yes.
Elizabeth Larrick (24:04.906)
And that’s kind of one of those things people say, Well, I’d rather, you know, ask for forgiveness than permission. And I think, you know, well, no. And I also think that’s also you are an over preparer. You you you really outwork people. And that’s a big piece of it, is just making sure you are gonna follow the courtroom rules, even if that means you are up to that line as close as possible.
Michelle Gessner (24:29.07)
Right. Absolutely. The jury is watching what the judge does. And the judge can make or break your case. And so if you cross that line, the jury’s rarely gonna say, The judge is a jerk, so I’m gonna fine for the plaintiff. Right. So having the judge be your just a neutral it is best. You know, if your friend, great, but just a neutral is what I really shoot for. And part of that is just respecting them, respecting what they want, respecting what they’ll allow. And if I do push it, I normally
you know, do it very cautiously and then have a backup for why, you know, a research reason why. So then a record. So learning to make a record and appease the judge and try your case to the jury, it’s not easy. And I think that’s why so many people are scared when it comes time to try a case, but don’t be, you’ve got a list of focus groups are the backbone of my trials. And, you know, it definitely works. It’s part of the prep is the focus groups. And they’re not that difficult to do.
You know, it’s about an hour and hour and a half, and what you learn from it is tremendous. So Elizabeth is the best at it. Reach out to her. Again, I you know, she is my right hand. Having be a small firm, I really feel like very much that you’re part of our firm, even on an outside basis. But big case or a small case, I one thing your ideas given your experience and thousands of focus groups that you’ve done. Those
It’s like a bell you can’t unring. You hear the sentiments and they apply multifaceted. So I appreciate all that you do for us.
Elizabeth Larrick (25:57.706)
Absolutely. Well, it’s a joy to work with you. So and I appreciate you coming on the podcast to share your advice and really a how-to on using AI for people who, you know, you’re cautious, you’re trying things, you know, and AI is here to help us. And I really appreciate you joining the podcast for these past two episodes to tell us about how you did it.
Michelle Gessner (26:19.244)
Thank you so much. I appreciate it. Take good care.
Elizabeth Larrick (26:22.346)
All right, thank you all so much for listening. Don’t forget if you missed the first episode 170, go back and grab that. The link will be in the show notes. If you have more questions for Michelle, I know she is open to those, and her contact will be in the show notes as well. So there you have it. Michelle used AI in her hotel room between trial days to make sure she’d met her burden of proof, helped her give her closing argument with
Those foam boards instead of any PowerPoint slides or technology, and she leaned into movement in the courtroom. And the result, you heard it, she won. And she got punitive damages. Fantastic. This is actually the kind of real-world AI strategy that trial lawyers need to hear. It’s not theory and it’s not complicated.
And you can see, as Michelle told you, she’s just one lawyer with a paralegal and her daughter, how they all together made that work. If you want more trial prep insights, just like this every month, even with extra resources, make sure that you’re on my email newsletter. I send out a newsletter with case tips strategies, and I sit out a second email with focus group trends.
A report that tells you what’s actually happening right now in jury research. Both are free, and the link is in the show notes for you to join. Thank you for listening to Trial Lawyer Prep. I’m your host, Elizabeth Larrick, and keep on prepping to win.
My guest today, Michelle Gessner, joined the podcast back in December of 2024, where we discussed her $21 million verdict against Wells Fargo.
Today she’s back with the story of a recent verdict success in North Carolina, which suddenly hit an unexpected twist.
The case was planned out to make use of high tech video equipment and software, as you would find in a standard, modern equipped court room.
But then, it was moved to courtroom that had no technology; in fact, only a single outlet with extension cords.
No microphones, no TVs, no projectors. Just old-school visual tools: easels, display boards, pen and notepads, and the projection of your own voice.
So how does one pivot, and still incorporate the planned visuals and presentation? AI to the rescue! What was already a useful tool was now needed to address the extra challenge of creating courtroom visuals in a no-technology courtroom.
Michelle and I explore how she started by using focus groups to find out weaknesses, then identified what needed to be visual, how to be visual under these unique circumstances, and ultimately AI’s creative suggestions. And the focus groups were the key, providing critical demonstratives to bring to life the evidence very early in the case.
If you want more trial prep strategies just like this, but in more depth and delivered straight to your inbox, grab my email newsletter that I send out each month:
Michelle Gessner is one of the few lawyers, if not the only lawyer, in North Carolina who has both Big Law and Big Company defense experience, as well as 10 years of employee-side employment litigation experience, which she has been nearly exclusively handling since 2015.
Michelle possesses a deep understanding of the many challenges employees face dealing with wage theft and other illegal employment practices.
Prior to its formation, Michelle gained extensive experience in all legal issues facing the retail, restaurant, and hospitality industries by serving as the Chief Litigation and Employment Law Counsel for publicly traded companies such as Family Dollar Stores, Inc. (FDO), Darden Restaurants, Inc. (DRI), Big Lots Stores, Inc. (BIG) and TriNet (TNET). Michelle also served as the SVP, General Counsel, and Chief Administrative Officer for Ovation Brands, a privately held $1 billion restaurant company.
Episode Transcript
Elizabeth Larrick (00:00.522)
Before we dive into today’s topic, just a quick note. If you’re not on my email list, you’re missing out on two things I send every single month. First, my monthly newsletter with deep dives on case pep, trial strategy, and witness preparation. And second, my focus group trends report, where I share what’s actually happening in jury research right now. That’s two valuable emails each month, and it’s free.
Just head over to Lariclaw Firm.com slash newsletter. L-A-R-R-I-C-K, lawfirm.com slash newsletter after this. Okay, now let’s get to this episode where we talk with Michelle Gessner about her recent verdict using AI.
Elizabeth Larrick (00:52.462)
Hello and welcome back to Trial Lawyer Prep. I’m your host, Elizabeth Larick, and we have a returning guest for you today to talk about a recent verdict and more specifically about how to use AI to create visuals for the courtroom. So welcome back to the podcast, Michelle Gessner.
Michelle Gessner (01:11.362)
Thank you so much for having me again.
Elizabeth Larrick (01:13.3)
Of course, Michelle joined the podcast back in December of 2024, where we discussed her $21 million verdict against Wells Fargo. I’ll have a link in the show notes for those episodes, but if you wanted to know, that’s episode 128 and 129. But for this episode, I want Michelle to talk to us about a recent verdict success, but more specifically about her use of technology.
to go into a no technology courtroom. So Michelle, give us just a quick billboard about the case. And again, you know, don’t worry everybody, Michelle is 100% a fabulous employment lawyer, but what she is gonna teach us today cannot be apple to any type of law that you may practice. So okay, Michelle, let me get out of the way. Tell Miss a little bit about the case.
Michelle Gessner (02:04.962)
Sure. This particular case was a sexual harassment, hostile work environment case that was filed in Wilmington, North Carolina federal court. All of the parties lived in Sneeds Ferry, North Carolina. The employee was a front of the house manager in a local small restaurant who had had, unfortunately, she testified the biggest mistake of her life.
Had had a relationship with the owner of the business. They had worked together, they started a relationship, and then as adults, they thought the relationship could end and still work together. that didn’t happen. And so the claims in this case were sexual harassment, hostile environment, together with some waging hour cases. Once she filed her hostile environment, sexual harassment case, the company then withheld her bonuses and withheld some of her wages. So
That’s just the elevator speech, if you will, regarding the case. It was filed in Wilmington, North Carolina in federal court in the Eastern District of North Carolina. And for those of you who may or may not be familiar, the eastern district of North Carolina is a really large geographic scope. And so the parties lived in Sneads Ferry, which is on the coast, close to Topsail Beach, if anybody knows that location. And the case was filed in Wilmington, but we were assigned a judge.
In Raleigh. So immediately we had a different location for where this case was ultimately going to be tried as opposed to the community in which these people lived. And then the case got moved. So after summary judgment, the case gets moved to Elizabeth City, North Carolina, to a different judge. So the furthest point away.
From Wilmington, North Carolina is Elizabeth City, so it’s really close to Norfolk, Virginia, about forty five miles outside of Norfolk, Virginia, closer to the Outer Banks. So that’s where the case was ultimately tried.
Elizabeth Larrick (04:01.378)
And what’s so special about this particular judge?
Michelle Gessner (04:05.42)
Okay, great question. So just backpedaling a bit, our original judge was Judge Dever. He’s in Raleigh and who’s pretty high tech, very high tech. Everything was expected to use the video equipment, every exhibit was expected to be uploaded. Again, documents were backup only, which is the norm in most federal courthouses. However, in Elizabeth City, the courthouse is very old. And there’s only really one major courtroom in that building. So
That particular judge, Judge Boyle, who happens to be the longest standing federal court judge in the United States right now, who’s not on senior status. So I think that’s important. had no technology. None. So there’s one outlet, that outlet, there’s a lot of extension cords. The clerk uses that outlet, and the court reporter uses that outlet. So there are no microphones, the judge or us.
There are no TVs, there are no projectors, there is no overhead projector. The only thing you have in that courtroom to try your case is your voice, foam boards and easels if you bring them, and notepads. That’s it.
Elizabeth Larrick (05:18.53)
Yeah. So you were gearing up for a different kind of trial. They switch it around on you. And so before we jump into, you know, that big changeup, because that’s the main what we’re gonna talk about. What I want you to walk us through is preparing for trial just generally. You knew that there were gonna be some immediate hangups that people would have. Okay, you had a relationship with the boss, but now you’re suing the boss. Like, you know. So you knew there were gonna be some issues. So talk to us through a little bit about.
Using focus groups to kind of figure out strengths and weaknesses. And then we’ll talk about how you pivoted to visualizing that for the courtroom. So walk us through the focus group planning.
Michelle Gessner (05:57.358)
Sure. And of course I have to give props to you, Elizabeth. Again, helping us through the focus groups from beginning to end in this case was huge. And we did a lot of focus groups, as we always do when we’re preparing for trial. But this time, having learned lessons from the Billiston case, the Wells Fargo case, we started pretty early with focus groups. So we learned early on that we needed visuals because there was a large time period. This employee had worked at this restaurant since I think like two thousand and seventeen.
And the time frame of the trial of this case was October of twenty twenty five. And so there was a long time period. There was pre-relationship, there was relationship, and then there was post relationship. But focusing only on the claims, which were obviously post-relationship, there was still a large scope of time there mainly because of COVID. So what we learned during focus groups were several things. And just really given the high level is that a timeline was really confusing.
Having a timeline of events here of just dates and events that happened, it was so much time that needed to be covered that the critical events that you really wanted the jury to focus on were getting buried. So that’s one thing that we really learned, and we would not have learned at all, but for focus groups. We also learned what jurors were not going to be great for us. You know, what characteristics about someone’s background.
Or whatever biases they bring that you wouldn’t be able to, you know, we can get to voidir in a minute, but if you got any voidir, you weren’t going to be able to even ask about. And so that helped us in picking a jury, in knowing really what juror sentiments were going to be under this fact pattern. We knew we were dealing with a small restaurant. We knew we were dealing with this prior paramour, this prior relationship. And people were polarized about that. You know, you get what you get if you have a relationship with the boss.
And other people, no means no. And there was demographics, it was across demographics that people really believed one or the other, but it was really their personal experiences that made them have an opinion on those issues. And so multiple focus groups on not only visuals, what we needed, yeah, early on it was what do we need to put on the screen? What do they need to see?
Michelle Gessner (08:16.076)
What documents do they need to see? What are the critical pieces of evidence that in opening statement I really want to hone in on and how to do it? And then of course we tested opening statement as well, but we had to pivot because a lot of the focus groups were reliant upon being able to do it on the screen. So then not only were there issues with creating the timeline, it was then how do we bring home some of this critical evidence? So let me if you like, I’ll give an example, which is
In this situation, it wasn’t bad acts, if you will, of sexual harassment or a hostile work environment in one setting. I call it like a dog bite. You know, it was like one little bite and then the bite gets bigger and the bite gets bigger and bigger and bigger. And looking at just one, it might not be enough for the jury. They may not see that this was really harassment that affected her in such a way to deliver the verdict that they did. But
What we were able to do is take what we wanted to really try to portray to the jury and then put it into AI. We used Chat GPT and a couple of other sources to say, what’s a good way to demonstrate this? And, you know, I didn’t really even know how to describe this, other than to say, you know, progressively bad behavior that got worse and worse. And so working with AI, it came up with an Elizabeth, it came up with, you know, circles.
And really starting thinking like a bullseye. And we started with what was initially happening. So initially it was name-calling, talking about her behind her back, really bad mouthing her to other employees. And it was more words. Then the circle got bigger. The second layer of the circle was grabbing her arm, knocking over tables in the restaurant, pushing her, screaming at her, yelling at her.
And that was a second circle. And then the third circle, which was bigger, had even more. And it was very egregious. It was kicking in the bathroom door in front of customers while she was using the restroom, going to her house, kicking in her front door, breaking into her house, having someone to program her garage door so they could open it, putting a tracker on her car. And so even initially with AI, I kept thinking, how am I going to do this? How am I going to show this to the jury?
Michelle Gessner (10:40.194)
But one of the things that came back that was really helpful was think an old school picture book where you flip through it like the cartoon books. You had to draw it on every page and flip through it, and that really brought it to light. Well, that’s what it suggested that we do, and we did, which is start with the small circle, but then when you show the second circle, keep the small circle on the board and just show it continuously getting bigger. And so then you see all of the postal environment facts, all of the evidence that supported the case related to.
How she was treated on the job in one poster, in one poster board and in one slide. And so, but for having known exactly what the jury needed to hear, and did the sequence matter? Was it the sequence of events that happened, or was it the severity of the events that happened? Or both? And did the dates matter? Was it more just it didn’t matter when this happened? If it happened at all, it was critical. And so
Again, you know, I would say that that was a critical demonstrative to bring to life the evidence very early in the case that we only learn through using focus groups.
Elizabeth Larrick (11:45.198)
Gotcha. And I would say just to kind of go back with the focus groups that you were doing and just kind of break this down a little bit. So what I hear you saying is number one, you had a list of bad behavior and initial attitudes fell into two chaos. and I remember, you know, we were at the time using kind of neutral narratives. If you’re thinking through like how did she focus group this, she used she did again, if you listen to the other episodes.
small chunks of this, one hour at a time, one hour at a time, one hour at a time, you know, again, just to figure out, okay, what are the attitudes, what’s the blush, but also the ranking of the behavior, which, you know, Michelle, you did a great job describing. We initially were putting this on a timeline. And if you did that, there were large breaks in time. And it was hard to see an escalation. Like it was hard to kind of picture, you know, do that as well. So that significantly helped, I think
Because what we learned were once the behavior got to a certain place, it was almost a timping point for the jurors that were against us where they’re like, wait a second, this is well beyond whatever their initial blush was. So I will say, you know, thinking through like she had a long list of stuff. Well, we didn’t know, is this enough to get other people on our side? You know, that that kind of good stuff.
Michelle Gessner (13:07.852)
One of the other things that came out of what you just said is how much what people are willing to put up with. You know, a lot of jury sentiment on that particular issue was why didn’t she just leave? That was polarizing with, you know, what is too much? And then why didn’t she just leave? You know, some people thought she should just quit. She should have just left as opposed to stand up for her rights. But also people are very you know, employees are willing to put up with a lot of really bad behavior.
and just walk away because they’re fearful of the system. That was something that we learned out out of those focus groups as well on those topics you were just discussing.
Elizabeth Larrick (13:43.586)
Absolutely. And I think one of the things the context that was so important for people again knowing you knew from the very outset we’re not gonna be trying this case in the neighborhood. We’re not gonna be in the community. So we have to set context and what context was important, if we were a rally or where we’re gonna be. And so, you know, I think also one of the things you learned was, okay, we need to tell them very upfront, like
She’s making really good money working at this restaurant. And she did a lot of things to increase profit. I mean, she had put a lot of blood and sweat into the restaurant to make it what it was. And so, you know, she had kind of a vested interest well before the romance. And, you know, so there were really good context clues that helped us. And again, thinking through how Michelle did it, you know, she tested a little different context along the way that, you know, basically, you know, Sneeds Farms, this tiny place.
She know where to work. She got this job, like was doing really well, like so well he promoted her to a manager. Then they start dating and then, you know, then the roller coaster begins. But I do think, you know, using focus groups the way that you did here in this case was really helpful. Then, like you said, from the very beginning to figure out, okay, how do we take all this information and make it into a digestible visual
That gets people like even if we have people who are against us, let’s like ’cause that’s my next question for you about like, okay, so you did all this research. How did it pan out for jury selection? You know, knew that we would have a tipping point for people where it’s just like, whoa, this is this is well beyond that. So tell us a little bit about how you worked hard to kind of figure out juror demographics. You’re gonna get ready for Voidier. How did that turn out ultimately a trial for Voidier?
Michelle Gessner (15:30.606)
Well, we’re body here. We didn’t get any. The judge didn’t. in fact, I had not tried a case in front of this judge before. And so when we walked in, there wasn’t really a large group of people in the jury pool. There were maybe, maybe 15, maybe, yeah, 15 to 20 max. And we received a seating chart with 13 people’s names already, a seat assigned.
13 people were put into the box, not called. They were just put into the box. And the judge proceeded with voidier. So we didn’t get to ask a single question. So I had to listen very carefully. I had to have a jury profile really built. And to your point that you mentioned earlier, and this is really important, one issue, one focus group. So every focus group, we really tested really one issue. And so we did get some.
Extraneous issues associated or extraneous information that we were able to use, but really we were testing one issue at a time. But I had a jury profile based upon those focus groups. We had researched very significantly the demographics of the counties from which the jury was coming. And Wadhir took less than an hour. And the judge I’d asked him if we could ask questions. He said, Nope, absolutely.
You know, and he brought us up to the stand and said, Do you guys have anything else you want to ask? And we gave him a couple of things and he asked what we were literally going off of the information learned from the multiple focus groups that we had done, the information that the juror shared with us to the questions the judge asked, and really some of the demographics of where people were pulled from.
And I thought that was really important for the verdict. You know, this particular area of North Carolina, the average income for most counties was twenty five thousand dollars a year. The highest was Dare County, which is the Outer Banks. And it was slightly higher, mainly because of tourism and a lot of restaurants, retail, et cetera. Now we didn’t get a single juror from Dare County. It was about an hour drive to get from there to the courthouse in Elizabeth City. So just from happenstance, I don’t know. Of course, we will never know, but we didn’t get a any jurors from Dare County.
Elizabeth Larrick (17:36.662)
Gotcha. Gotcha. So super helpful. Now let’s walk back through. I want you to kind of break down how you and again, I you don’t I don’t need you to get into my nitty gritty here, but tell us a little bit more about using AI to get creative, if you can.
Michelle Gessner (17:53.464)
Sure. Yeah, I can do that. So again, feedback from the focus groups and knowing what were our strong points and what were some of the places we really needed to do more to show them what was happening, we needed AI’s help. So I was able to put into AI really almost hypotheticals that we could come up with and to see if they could come up with more. And they did. It did a vague. I call ChatGPT Chet. So Chet came up with more and then just refining it. And it came up with
ways to the circles that I was telling you about. The other way was, you know, checklists. Think about the right way to do things, even for a small business versus the wrong way to do things. And there was a checklist that I was able to use for every witness. I didn’t have to check off anything, but it was really the right way to run a restaurant, the right way to treat employees. One of the Zings Focus Group told us is what do people expect from small restaurants?
Elizabeth Larrick (18:46.86)
Special.
Michelle Gessner (18:50.814)
Is there a distinction between what they expect from the large mega companies compared with a small mom and pop at the beach? You know, those were the kinds of things we got from focus groups and then how to bring that to life, what words to choose, how to put them on something that I could use throughout the trial. So I had one checklist that I really use with every single witness. One other thing I would say is defendants called in witnesses. I think there were four people that I had never met.
Never deposed, never heard of. They were listed, you know, on a discovery response. So my cross-examination of each of these people was very short, but really focused on the things that we had already researched. And I used those checklists really to bring them back around. And so it became a little bit of a security blanket, if you will, during trial to attach to the checklists and the circles, the evidence on the circles that had come in to really even cross-examine.
People off the cuff. I had no idea they were coming. They didn’t disclose who was coming ahead of time. We didn’t know the order of the witnesses. It was a true off-the-cuff cross-examination. But the jury focused groups, together with AI, on how to present some of the information we needed, it became a way to just circle back, really echoing back some of what other witnesses had said and really getting some of these unknown witnesses to just substantiate what other witnesses had said. But using as a tool,
I’m showing you my hands because I had a phone board. Yeah. We’ll get in that that had these checklist items on the right way and the wrong way to do things. And it just became a visual that I could connect each witness with that I could just use over and over.
Elizabeth Larrick (20:20.226)
Yeah.
Elizabeth Larrick (20:31.606)
Right. And just to tap into a little bit of that, what you’re doing for the jury, which is one organization. And you’re being repetitive in a way that is appreciative, not you know, there are times where people will echo or repeat something and it’s it it’s too much. It’s like you’re hitting them on the head with this, like this is not persuasive, versus the way that you presented it was one an organizational tool for both of you for you, for but also just to know like
We’re all on the same page, even though these are, you know, and again, because the jury doesn’t know at that point that these are people you’ve never seen before, you’ve never talked to before. Like they don’t know that, right? And so even if you’d asked that question, have we met before? Have we like that still would be lost on the jury. So I love that you, you know, and you would did this very well in the Billson case, which was like, I’m sticking to my guns. I know what this trial is about. I am not changing what my theme is, or just because you’re throwing
a new witness at me, or in the case of the Billston, and I’m sure this case too, which was testimony you had never heard before about your particular client. So awesome. Let me take it back just a second here because I know a lot of people when we talk about using AI, we talk about using visuals, there’s always a little pushback from lawyers, especially maybe even our mind, like it’s gonna get objected to, I’m gonna have to show them like this phone board ahead of time. So
Tell me how you walked through that in your mind and then if you faced any of that at trial.
Michelle Gessner (22:01.272)
Yeah, great question. I did focus the demonstratives, all of them, the circles, as well as the checklists, on evidence that I knew was going to come in. Either it was in a deposition, it was in a pleading. It was not something that I think was ever going to be objectionable. It was more about organizing it in a way that it was effective. So AI helped me do that.
I was able to upload, you know, depositions that were already filed. The Eastern District makes you file your full deposition when you file briefs, the summary judgment briefs. So we normally don’t put anything in AI that doesn’t have a filed stamp on it because at least then we know it’s not going to get disclosed in any way. And so, you know, making sure that whatever I have in a demonstrative, there’s a record site to it in case that I have somebody to question me on it.
This judge did not require us to share the demonstratives before the day first day of trial, but on the first day of trial we did. We shared. I didn’t want to get the objection during opening. And so opposing counsel had an opportunity to see everything that we were gonna present. And I was ready for those objections if he was going to object, but he didn’t. And so
But yes, so you know, one, the perfect world is make sure you’ve got a record site and you’ve really got like a pocket brief ready that if they’re going to object, you’re creating your record to show that you’re not showing something that they haven’t seen or heard of before. It might just be the way it’s being outlined for the jury. And then the second is if you want to push the envelope, some things are just common sense. You know, some of the things that we put, the qu all the jury instructions are always gonna have an element that says you can use your common sense jury.
And so some of what was in our checklist, for example, like treat people with respect or, you know, treat people with dignity when they go to the bathroom. Right. And so those were common sense items that were on the checklist that I was really ready to have that argument. Because think about it, defense counsel looks foolish if they want to get up and say, She needs to remove this, that people have to be treated with dignity when they go.
Elizabeth Larrick (24:01.838)
And respect, yeah. Yeah. That’s not in the law. We don’t have that yep.
Michelle Gessner (24:06.616)
Right. But I get it. You know, AI tends to be a people pleaser. You know, I’m a cynic. I guess I’ve been doing this a long time. So sometimes I have fights with chat, like, huh, you know, how about give me a no every now and again? I’m l need help here. I don’t need you to give me a yes man. Yeah. it was not a one and done. That’s what I want to say is that I don’t think people will outwork me. And so that takes a lot of time. What I’m saying is it wasn’t one sit down with AI and say, let’s come up with this. It was
Leading up to trial, probably multiple days and hours. You know, I found myself sitting here for like two hours one time, just nonstop having a conversation with AI about how to try this case. Even during trial, how pieces of evidence were coming in in the ho in my hotel room between day one and two, I was making sure that I had met my burden of proof.
Like using AI to make sure what had known what I knew came in because we had the exhibits obviously marked and could say this is what came in, what do I need to have and was there anything I needed for closing? And we can talk about that because in closing we did not have
Elizabeth Larrick (25:12.622)
Let’s not give away all, let’s not give away everything here in our first jump here at now. Don’t forget we are going to separate this into two episodes. So before we get into what happened in the courtroom and you using AI during and then also juror reactions, let’s take a pause here and end this episode. And then don’t forget, y’all, stick around, come back to that next episode that we’re going to have to talk about how it worked out in the courtroom.
Our next episode, Michelle’s gonna tackle how did she use AI during the trial and also how did it work in the courtroom, jury visuals, how did you know it was working, and then of course talk about the verdict.
Michelle Gessner (25:51.246)
Thank you so much, appreciate it.
Elizabeth Larrick (25:52.96)
Okay, until next time, keep on prepping to win.
And that’s it for part one of my conversation with Michelle Gessner. We’ve covered how she used AI to build objection-proof court visuals, organized her trial prep with focus groups, and got ready to try case in a courtroom with a literally one outlet. But here’s what you don’t know yet. So tune in. How did she actually use AI during the trial itself?
What did the jury think of her visuals? And more importantly, what was the outcome? What was the verdict? Don’t miss part two. That’s episode 171 where Michelle walks us through exact what happened in the courtroom. And if you want more trial prep strategies, just like this, but in more depth, delivered straight to your inbox, grab my email newsletter I send out each month. You will get a
trial prep newsletter, which will have episodes and also deep dives, and my second email, which is a focus group trends where you learn what is happening in jury research right now. The link to that newsletter will be in the show notes. Until next time, keep on prepping to win.
What if our assumptions about modern juror attention spans aren’t accurate?
We are all used to hearing that people have much, much shorter attention spans these days, thanks to social media, clickbait, algorithms, and a constant barrage of information.
While those things certainly represent a major shift in our day to day reality over the past 15+ years, that doesn’t necessarily mean that we’re paying less attention than we used to.
In fact, it’s more of a rewiring of our brains, thanks to technology, leading to a state of continuous partial attention.
Why is this important to trial law, case framing, focus groups and understanding juries? Because understanding how our brains have changed will then help you package and present your case in a more intentional, and effective way.
When I work with lawyers and focus groups, we work very hard on your presentations to make sure that they’re fitting our attention spans. To learn more about this process, book a free call with mehere.
In this episode, we cover:
How continuous partial attention means our focus is shallow, but long.
How brains cannot multitask; they toggle between tasks.
Why visual aids should amplify concepts, not repeat them.
How jurors can easily get lost during long presentations.
Re-entry points in presentations are crucial for audience understanding.
Remember to check out Episode 144 of Trial Lawyer Prep,The 8 Second Rule That’s Costing You Verdicts, to learn more about the brain science behind attention spans:
Don’t miss out on the Trial Lawyer Prep Newsletter that is delivered right to your email with extra tips and ‘how to’ information. Join the newsletter here:
For an effective discovery, case framing should start as early as possible. But be ready to pivot!
Don’t let the other side get the jump on you in framing a case, and put you in catch-up mode from the start. You need to start framing a case at intake, especially for higher-value cases.
But, as our guest points out today, you also need to be ready and willing to pivot, should new facts arise, or if a new framing will in fact strengthen your case.
Tony Edwards is a personal injury lawyer in Oklahoma, and shares stories and wisdom from his decades of experience. We talk about a trucking case where digging into personnel records uncovered that the driver had previously been fired for on-the-job drug use, convincing Tony and his team to pivot to a stronger employer-focused theory, and a settlement at trial for the prior demand.
Focus groups are a great help for this kind of shift, since you’ll instantly receive feedback on what works and what doesn’t, and particularly what may go against your own assumptions and expectations. You then just need to be willing to adjust!
Early focus groups change how you build a case, and build a case frame. Book a free call with me and learn more about my online focus groups for plaintiff personal injury lawyers.
In this episode, we cover:
How discovery can significantly change the framing of a case.
That strategic questioning in discovery is key to uncovering information.
Pulling from real-world examples to illustrate the impact of effective case framing.
How focus groups can reveal unexpected insights about case issues.
That AI can assist but should not replace human review.
Why attorneys should not hesitate to seek help from peers.
Tony Edwards was born and raised in McAlester, Oklahoma and has devoted himself to serving the legal needs of the people in his home area. He received his undergraduate degree in sociology and psychology from East Central University in Ada and then went to Oklahoma University College of Law, receiving his J.D. in 1982.
In 2006, Tony decided to that he wanted to create a smaller firm that would give him an opportunity to provide more personal service. The Edwards firm was born that year, and he has continued to concentrate on plaintiff’s civil litigation. His practice today encompasses cases involving motor vehicles, nursing homes, defective products, and oil-field injuries. He has been involved in numerous mass-tort cases involving defective products.
Edwards and Patterson began in 2015 when he became partners with Matt Patterson. His efforts have resulted in numerous significant verdicts and settlements for his clients.
Don’t miss out on the Trial Lawyer Prep Newsletter that is delivered right to your email with extra tips and ‘how to’ information. Join the newsletter here:
Hello there, it’s your host, Elizabeth Larrick. I want to jump in real quickly to give you an introduction for our wonderful guest for this episode, Tony Edwards. Tony Edwards is the founding partner and personal injury trial attorney for Edwards and Patterson Law. They have several offices across Oklahoma. He is gonna join us to talk about case framing here today and his experience. I hope you enjoy.
Hello and welcome to the podcast. I’m your host, Elizabeth Larrick, and today we have a treat for you. We have a guest, Tony Edwards. He is joining us from Oklahoma, and we are gonna talk about one of the my favorite things, which is getting started early in a case with case framing. So welcome to the podcast, Tony.
Tony Edwards (00:49.858)
Thank you very much. Thanks for having me.
Elizabeth Larrick (00:51.918)
Well, I was excited when we got connected because I know how important it is to get things started early in a case so that you can really use everything as best as possible. So when we talked about talking case framing and discovery, and you had a couple of great examples and something that your firm likes to do that is pretty unique, even starting in pre-lit, I thought I need to have you on so that we can tell other folks about what you’re doing. so
Tell us a little bit about kind of how this started and and really kind of what case framing means for you.
Tony Edwards (01:26.478)
Well, for us it’s really just determining very early on the issues involved and then trying to to collect the facts and information that we can tailor those issues the way we want them to be presented to a jury ultimately. but a lot of people think that case framing starts when the case is filed and when you get into discovery, but but we do this when we originally sign up a case.
In our firm, about a third, maybe forty percent of our cases are in litigation, the remainder being in prelid. In many cases it get settled in prelit. But anytime what we call our our top two levels of cases, which are basically s six-figure cases with that much injury and insurance coverage, we decide to case frame those at the very beginning. Now, obviously those frames can change drastically during the process, but at least we want everyone to
in our staff and in in our court, so to speak, to be on the same page as how we’re going to present this case ultimately. Even if it’s in prelit, we want a people or a whether it’s an associate or one of the partners or even a a case manager to be able to tell an adjuster, hey, this is the way this is going to be framed. We don’t say it that way exactly. But we want them to have that approach from the very beginning. If it doesn’t get worked out and we wind up in litigation, then that case frame continues along with it and that can
can change through the discovery process as well.
Elizabeth Larrick (02:58.338)
Gotcha. So give us give us a quick example about what you mean if you you have a case that that comes in. Tell us a little bit about how that works.
Tony Edwards (03:07.48)
Well, th there’s three of us that will sit down, the the committee or so to speak, it’s my partner, myself, and and the associate attorney that will be handling the case. we sit down and talk about all the facts that we know. Usually we don’t have a lot of things like witness statements and that sort of thing, but we place a really a rough value on the case and then start framing those issues and saying, Well, if if this person was a passenger, for instance
the way you frame that is going to be much different than if you’ve got a driver out here who was potentially had some negligence. And the way you you propose those issues, not only in in talking to adjusters or lawyers, but certainly in the way you talk to witnesses, that makes a big difference usually in the information that we can collect then.
Elizabeth Larrick (03:56.162)
Gotcha. So give me give me an example that you may have off the top of your head.
Tony Edwards (04:00.546)
Well, we have we had a trucking case last year, that significant injuries, bad accident, had another death in another vehicle and and a lot of things going on with it, and we had to frame that in such a way that we wanted the real thrust of the case to be against the employer, the trucking company, as opposed to the truck driver, which made it difficult because the truck driver was had a lot of faults and was not a very likable person.
would have been an easy target. But we felt like for the the best recovery for our client, we wanted the target to be more on the company as opposed to the to the driver. So after doing a lot of discovery, we d we found some things that allowed us to really put the the target on the company as opposed to the driver. And that I think really increased the value of that claim tremendously.
Elizabeth Larrick (04:54.982)
Gotcha. And so, you know, trucking cases, you know, there’s gonna be most of the time a trucking company. Sometimes there’s not, sometimes the the driver is the owner, kind of a thing. But tell me like let’s talk maybe, give me an example about a premises case where like what is the frame that you may use there?
Tony Edwards (05:10.946)
Well, in premises cases, I we have a policy here that if we’re suing a r retailer, any kind of corporate entity, they’re going to have their own policies and procedures for most any incident that occurred. And it’s it vitally important to get those because I can assure you that they are not doing everything that their corporate policies are saying telling them to do. They’re just not doing them. And
That happens to all of us. We don’t follow all the rules. We find some ways to cut corners and different things. And that happens a lot in those kind of premises cases. I mean they’re the largest retailer around right now, their policies and procedures can be very damning to them and the way they actually run their stores. And things like trip and fall cases can drastically improve based on the information that you get from them. And it’s important to to get that.
It’s important to fight for that because th most of these companies will fight against it. But it’s really important to fight hard to get all those documents and then have if it’s a sizable enough case, then have your expert look at those and and can help provide you with some some framework and a a way to case frame those those cases. And sometimes you don’t really have a good you have a feel for it, but you don’t have the specifics that you need until you get into discovery. And that’s that’s why you’re the frame of your case.
can change it can be tweaked in discovery or it can change drastically in discovery. You just don’t know it’s it’s from case to case, but it usually does change some.
Elizabeth Larrick (06:47.862)
Sure. So maybe what I hear you saying is if we’re gonna talk real specifically, kind of you know, a safety rules is pretty much one of the you know, you’re looking for the rules, whether it’ll be employer rules or maybe even premises rules. What are the rules that we can show that they have violated? So case framing for you sometimes really centers around what are the rules involved with the parties.
Tony Edwards (07:11.468)
Yes. Many times you you don’t know exactly how you’re gonna frame that case until you get those rules. But retailers and larger corporations, we’ve sued them enough times to to know kind of what their policies are going to be, so we can frame it early on, but we don’t really firm that up until we get all those policies and procedures and other documents from them. but that just allows us so much fodder for depositions. I mean thirty B six and th those kind of depositions can
be so important in firming all of that
Elizabeth Larrick (07:44.738)
Gotcha. And then that’s sometimes that’s where you get extra gifts, where you can change your case framing.
Tony Edwards (07:50.95)
Absolutely. I d I mentioned earlier the the trucking case, one that we handled last year. We had discovery with typical accident. We did know that there was some drugs in the system of the truck driver. We got his employment his personnel file, all of these things. And and after looking at everything, we found there was one document in there that discussed him and his prior employment with this same company. Nothing in his personnel file reflected that other than one document and one little sentence. So we pushed hard enough and finally had to get court involvement, but we got got those records from his prior employment with the same company and he had been fired eight years earlier for drug use on the job. Well, that changed the whole frame to a degree because we were then able to really put that bullseye on the on the trucking company because they they fired a guy for drug using drugs. They hired him later and he’s using drugs again and caused another accident. And Ultimately that that turned out to be very, very good for us, but it did change the way we had that case framed somewhat, but it made it stronger a as we went. And we ultimately settled settled that case on as trial was beginning, we settled it for our demand of about four months earlier.
Elizabeth Larrick (09:07.042)
Gotcha. Gotcha. So tell me a little bit about how, you know, you talked a little about prelit, how that works. Let’s talk then a little bit about discovery. You know, when we think about doing discovery, we’ve got written questions, you know, request for production. We also have depositions. So tell me a little bit about how those things weave together kind of with case framing for you.
Tony Edwards (09:27.628)
Yeah, we always or almost always have a written discovery first. And those questions usually follow the frame of the case that we have we’re suggesting. We try not to make it obvious to the defendant that that’s what we’re doing with those questions, and because they can be kind of open ended, but get us the information that we need, and then in depositions we use that information and we don’t go in and just ask the questions along the lines that we have
the case frame this way, so these are the questions. But we go in and ask those questions, but we may intermix many other questions in other areas along with it. We get the information that we need, but the the biggest part is just doing a thorough job on the on the discovery. We’ve got a guy here that works for us, he’s I’ve counsel for us, and he is one of the best that I’ve I’ve seen in being so detail oriented and
thorough in reading documents, in in reading transcripts and those kind of things. And that’s what you need in order to find these these little nuggets and these these things that really firm up your case frame so that you can then go you’re not afraid to go to trial because you know exactly what you want to wanna show. And and that’s that happens.
Elizabeth Larrick (10:45.27)
Are you you know, it’s the time of AI. Are you using any AI to help do maybe a double check or maybe a first check on some of these like documents?
Tony Edwards (10:56.844)
We are, but it is only a first check. it is absolutely everything that we use AI for is verified by human eyes right after that happens. So but it is a good way to to condense a lot of information into some sort of volume size that we can actually work with. But I will say this, on those documents that are produced, AI doesn’t catch those things that that human eyes may catch about the guy being employed before.
or about a certain policy or procedure with a real retailer or something like that. You cannot depend on AI to to catch everything like that. And and it goes back to just good old time consuming review of those documents is what really gets you there.
Elizabeth Larrick (11:40.972)
Yeah, and I think especially in trucking cases, even premises cases, where you have still a lot of handwritten records, or, you know, it can be like you said, it’s that little nugget. I was talking with a lawyer just recently, and the whole case went around one piece of paper where they used whiteout. And it was like the only way somebody would have found that is with a human eye, you know. So I do 100% agree. Like, you know, there are still ways that we could use AI, but sometimes like digging through these files.
To find those nuggets it still takes a human eye.
Tony Edwards (12:12.622)
Very tr very true. We we need it for the vol for the volume of documents that we get.
Elizabeth Larrick (12:18.104)
But sure, yeah. I I think like you said, go through and an an and an organization I think also helps in in it from a from you know, for our human brain, like to sit down and think, my gosh, I gotta throw all of this, you know. How am I gonna organize that? But you know, that’s where sometimes I think that first go through helps. So have you ever used AI to help with any of your case framing?
Tony Edwards (12:39.97)
We have. actually one of the the systems that we have used basically we we plug everything in and it gives us strengths and weaknesses of your case right off the bat, which is great. But by the same token, we look at everything as well and s and those generally match, not always. And I I will admit I’ve gotten some ideas from those strengths and weaknesses that I was I did not catch when I reviewed the files. So it has some good
It points to it, certainly does.
Elizabeth Larrick (13:11.618)
Good, good, good, good. Well tell me a little bit about you kind of mentioned this a little bit and so we may have some people who are listening to this episode and they’re thinking, Well, now wait a second, Tony, I don’t wanna send all the signals and let all my all the magic tricks out of the bag too early. Am I revealing too much about my strategy if I’m dropping in questions in discovery, request for production, questions in deposition.
Tony Edwards (13:37.226)
short answer to that is is that I don’t believe that we are. And a lot of that has to do though with the way you articulate the questions, not only in depositions, but certainly in in written discovery as well. And that’s one reason that we use even though we may want to go a certain direction with questions, we don’t get very specific with those questions in order to keep our the frame that we’re really wanting to get to to kind of keep it
held back a little bit. We don’t want to give them a specific thing that we’re looking for without asking for a lot of other specific things. And that’s hard. That’s difficult to do sometimes. But we have to do it in order to try to hide that. I don’t for lack of a better word, we try to hide that that reason we’re asking those questions. But sometimes we just have to ask them and and let them know. I mean and most of the time
the way we have framed the case should be I won’t say obvious, but it should be something that a defense counsel would be able to to recognize at some point in time. So I’m not not trying to to hide anything, but we are trying to keep that low key until we absolutely have to get there through depositions and things like that. I I’m old enough to remember what we used to call trial by ambush. Our discovery was so so lax and so weak
that you could go to trial and the other side would not know what you’re gonna put on. That’s the way I I many times I’d like to be able to do that again, but it doesn’t work that way. And now we’re able to find as much good information from the defendant as we have from the plaintiff. So the old way of doing it is can go both ways. But the way it’s done now is just you have to go through and and detail by detail to get there.
And it’s a step by step. It’s the written discovery, and maybe two or three sets of written discovery to get certain details and then the depositions. And in the depositions, I i to me it would be pretty clear after all the depositions are done that the the defense is probably going to know how we have framed this case. And that’s just that’s just the nature of the beast.
Elizabeth Larrick (15:49.306)
sure, of course. And I think also, you know, you have to be gauging in how close is somebody else paying attention. Generally, I think you could probably tell us in your experience, I can tell you from mine, like they’re not paying attention until it comes to the bottom line. So you could totally be crafting something and you think you’re revealing everything and they’re just not paying attention to know what what’s happening, which is why
like you’re explaining, how we litigate cases has completely changed because now it is the back and forth, the motions to compel, the and setting up your case in discovery because it takes a long time to get to trial. You may not get there. And also, you know, you need them to be paying attention to how you’re setting this up. You need to be able to show them in mediation, like, we’ve destroyed this case and you didn’t even notice. You know, so there’s always you know, when people come to me about, we’re gonna reveal too much, like
You can’t have your you know, I’m like, why? This this is where the case now lies is in discovery.
Tony Edwards (16:47.096)
That that’s very true. And and many times I won’t say we do discovery and and ask certain things just for the mediation process, but it helps as much in mediation as it would be in trial. It to let them know, hey, we’ve we’ve got you here. You need to pay money. And that happens a lot. One other way that that I will say that changes our case framing some is is through mock trials and mock juries. We’ve done that online a few times.
And that’s has helped us tremendously, not trying to gauge values as much as we are issues. And those have helped. And sometimes we don’t do those until pretty late in the game and or late in the whole process. And we can’t do a lot of discovery after that. So it’s good to have done as much discovery across the board as we can do, because some of those issues may not come up until late until we find that out.
Elizabeth Larrick (17:39.862)
Right, right. Well, and I am a very, very huge proponent of doing focus groups before you file, right after you file, even before you get all the rest of your discovery, because they’re gonna show you things you miss. And you know, most of the time all the things that we talk about here on the podcast are doing online focus groups because they’re fast, they’re easier and you know, you’re not gonna set up a big mock trial until the end, but but yeah, they’re gonna s show you what you’ve missed or they’re gonna test your frame out and they’re gonna be like, I don’t
I don’t get it, right? You know, you don’t want them to be confused. So I obviously am a very big proponent of of using little ones along the way to really help you know if you’re setting things up correctly.
Tony Edwards (18:19.446)
Right, just to flesh out certain issues. I mean you may do a focus group on a particular issue and see how that plays. I mean not the whole case and that that happens as well. And that that’s very important. I mean i if the if the case warrants it size wise, the focus groups at the you know, very beginning, midway through, and then after discovery, all of those are very important.
Elizabeth Larrick (18:40.078)
Sure, sure. I mean an example I’m thinking of is we had a focus group where the framing was about qualifications for the commercial driver and specifically about something that the employer was not doing on their application. And, you know, I said, you know, you just take this to a focus group and see what they say. You think this is a big deal. I’m gonna take the bet on the other side and say this is not the biggest deal to them.
And sure enough, just that one little issue, right? Little setup, little and and they were just it didn’t make any difference to them, right? What w whether the application was correct, you know, according to the law or not. But it’s just little things like that that you can gain from short focus groups that really help you know, okay, let me drop that, let me focus energy somewhere else so that we can make sure and have the right frame.
Tony Edwards (19:30.508)
That very true. I mean, focus groups may really diminish what you think is gonna be something very impactful, but then they may also come up with something small that you just mention and they they grab hold of and say, Hey, this is important and you have to flesh that out then. So it it can go both ways with focus groups and I but I think they are very important and very productive.
Elizabeth Larrick (19:51.49)
Very, very helpful. Quick note before we get back to this episode, if you’re sitting on a case right now and you haven’t done any focus groups and you haven’t done any case framings, I want to help you fix that. I run online focus groups for plaintiff personal injury lawyers, one afternoon, a real set of jurors, and results you can actually use. No travel, no facility, no full day commitment.
And you’re gonna have my experience to help you along the way. Early focus groups change how you build a case, how you can build a case frame. That’s the whole point. The link will be in the show notes, or just go to lyriclawfirm.com. Back to the episode. Okay, so tell me a little bit, let’s let’s take this all the way now through to the end here. You talked a little bit about that that trucking case, so tell us a little bit about kind of
Walk us through that whole process and and you know, we know you had a successful end there. You had multiple cars, there were lots of you know, lots of things going on with our driver. So tell us a little bit how you frame things up against the employer.
Tony Edwards (20:57.228)
Yeah, that was the there were multiple ve multiple vehicles involved, multiple lawyers involved for the plaintiffs, because there were three three different vehicles with with injured plaintiffs and one deceased. And we kinda worked together some, but then that kind of fell apart through the process as well. But ultimately it was at the beginning when we were kind of working together, everyone asked a different type questions and we shared a lot of that information, which helped a lot. But we all had
framing issues because we didn’t all frame it the same way, especially as against the company itself. And by making the changes that we made, we were the first vehicle that was struck. And so obviously that helped us because of reaction time and things like that. If others didn’t react any better than or any differently than we did, they had more time. And so we went through all of that process with experts and different things.
But ultimately it got back to no matter what our reaction time was, no matter what happened anywhere else, the bottom line that we and the way we wanted to frame it to a jury was that this driver, the truck driver, had drugs in his system, was apparently a drugs that would affect him and his ability to drive. He came across the center line, we don’t know why, and caused this, you know, tremendous accident. That was the way we originally approached it and is saying, well
this driver was, you know, really at fault. This company should have supervised him much better and not allowed that to happen where he would be there, you know, with drugs and assistance, that sort of thing. Then we find out that he’s was employed by them before and had been fired because of those drug there because of drug use then, that gave us a whole new way or a whole new weapon to ask them questions and specific items and and it the thirty B six depositions then from their
corporate reps as well as their safety manager, we were very able to ask some very pointed questions and get some very good information from them because they just could not respond. Well, why would you fire him, hire him back, and then not supervise him appropriately? And they had no real response to that at all. And I think the way that we got to that framing through that discovery, we were able to to focus so much on the the company’s
Tony Edwards (23:23.648)
inability to do what they should do to keep the road safe, and they just refused. It’s not that they did they chose not to. They just looked the other way. They didn’t apparently didn’t care if their driver was driving under the influence of drugs. And that’s the the picture that we were painting. And I think we had that in very good shape. We had gone through three settlement conferences over a a period of of months. And then finally after we got all those depositions done and we had kind of
conveyed most of our information to them in those settlement conferences, certainly in the last one, they knew what we were going to do and what we were going to say. And because of that, the way we had framed everything there, I I suppose they were just going to wait and see if we showed up for trial. I don’t know what the deal was, but we do show up for trial and then they pay what we had demanded. So to me the the case framing did change, but it was because of that case framing and conveying that information to the defendant that ultimately got the case settled.
Now that was a great set of facts for us. That doesn’t doesn’t always happen, doesn’t usually happen. But that allowed us because of that that framing and the change of that framing that allowed us to get a very good result for our client.
Elizabeth Larrick (24:36.138)
Sure. I think, you know, it sounds to me like you started out with supervision. You knew somebody wasn’t supervising this driver if they were allowed to do this and then it turned into, well, hiring, right? Like. And then the back information about how much they knew about that person, you know, whenever we look at cases, I always, you know, the jury’s just wants to know what’s the first in time? Where’s the first place that we could have, you know, changed the trajectory and for this company they had a lot of back history.
for that person and being able to then ask like you said, ask those questions and then be able to frame up the motive, which is they just didn’t care, right? They hired the guy back and
Tony Edwards (25:16.098)
That’s the approach that we took. They just didn’t care.
Elizabeth Larrick (25:18.978)
Yeah, which worked out really well for depositions because then they answered with the way that they just didn’t care. So wonderful, wonderful. It’s nice when it all comes together. And even sometimes I always tell people, even if you don’t have the perfect set of facts and maybe you have a little bit of contrib, if you still push hard and frame up your case correctly, that’s where the jury will keep their eyes and their focus versus trying to be distracted by, you know, by the defense with other things that are going on with your client.
Tony Edwards (25:49.074)
That’s that’s exactly right. And the fact that the defence counsel and defense or insurance companies, if they know you’ll go to trial, they’re gonna pay more attention to you. And I think that’s that’s what you have to do. Sometimes you just have to try cases, but if you get to that point, they’re gonna probably pay you more money.
Elizabeth Larrick (26:07.918)
Sure, sure. And I would say for the most part, people always think that trial go ha you have the best set of facts with those cases and it typically the ones that go to trial are the ones that do not have the best set of facts. And so those are the ones you really have to then sit down and say, Okay, we’ve gotta have a solid case frame. We’ve gotta have some good strategy here for putting this thing the best foot forward at every step of the way.
Tony Edwards (26:31.566)
Right. Many times you’re you’re the ones that are tried, there’s a a question about liability and and damages are kind of ignored. And those are the ones that can obviously you can get a zero verdict because of of that, but obviously just as obviously, the defense has some exposure there because if they don’t if they follow the plaintiff on the liability part, they don’t really contest the damages as much and you can get a a really good sized verdict. And that has happened to us in the in the years past as well.
Elizabeth Larrick (27:00.59)
Sure. And that just goes back to the point that they’re not paying attention until it comes time to dance, right?
Tony Edwards (27:06.166)
Yeah, that’s exactly right. I think. And sometimes the defense counsel do, but they don’t get I don’t think they get their insurance companies attention until it’s very late in the game. And I I think that’s a bad way to do it, but insurance companies make millions of dollars, so I guess they’re doing something right. But as much as some of them as I can.
Elizabeth Larrick (27:21.838)
Well, you know, Hey, right. You know, I don’t always, you know, I always some you know, lately I would say in the past several years, like, you know, the ability of defense counsel to do their job has been very hampered by the structure of the insurance company and those kinds of things. So I do think there’s a lot of cases and your your trucking case is a great example of one where like things just are not getting to the level of priority until the very last minute when risk is very obvious.
Tony Edwards (27:52.192)
Right.
Elizabeth Larrick (27:53.058)
Yeah. so a lot of people are having to go right up literally to the courthouse steps or picking even picking the jury before, you know, all of a sudden somebody comes in. Okay, we have authority now, like, you know, here’s your number. Wonderful. well do you have I it’s one you know, open it up. Do you have any other examples that you would want? I mean, we talked a little bit about premises, but did you have any other examples that you wanted to walk us through before we wrap up?
Tony Edwards (28:16.838)
e examples I I you know, with with most cases, it’s more of a looking at documents with a fine tooth comb and that’s what’s gonna get you the information that you need. Ninety percent of time you’re going to learn something by doing that. Even if you think you have your case framed perfectly and you’re you’re in great shape, if you really look through those documents with corp I’m talking about with corporate defendants, you’re probably gonna find something that will help a lot.
And it’s it’s all about that hard work that to do that. And and that does take time, but you just have to put it in.
Elizabeth Larrick (28:53.512)
Absolutely, absolutely. And if you don’t have the documents, ’cause sometimes we they’re just you got no policies or procedures, you got no there’s nothing written right. There that’s a whole other set of case frame. that makes depositions way more fun, I would say, sometimes.
Tony Edwards (29:08.254)
Exactly right. I was just gonna say that makes things fun because you can’t go any direction there, so
Elizabeth Larrick (29:14.476)
That’s right, that’s right. But it’s always, you know, sometimes I always feel like case framing i is a lot more about us as lawyers having the discipline, right, to stick to the plan versus going off script and starting cross examining people and, you know, doing things that you know, that’s the fun stuff, you know, when people are saying the all the wrong things in deposition. But being disciplined to stick with the plan is sometimes part of our excitement.
Tony Edwards (29:39.5)
Very true. Some the depositions can be very f very fun, but all the work getting ready for that depositions, that’s where the the hard work comes in.
Elizabeth Larrick (29:47.576)
Sure, sure, sure. Of course, of course. Well, Tony, thank you so much for joining Trial Lawyer Prep. I know that this conversation will be so helpful to others that are either maybe they’re starting out with case framing or they’re trying to think about a way to build their cases a little bit better. Would you have any other pieces of advice for folks who are maybe dipping their toe in the water to do this earlier?
Tony Edwards (30:10.008)
The only thing that I would tell everyone is don’t hesitate to ask for help, whether that’s from another lawyer in your town, another friend of yours or somebody who’s across the country, lawyers typically will help each other tremendously. And I’m not talking about referring and splitting fees and all that. I’m just talking about asking for help. Do that. I mean I I would tell anyone that has not done a lot of this kind of work.
And that and by that I mean trial work and trucking cases and premises cases and that sort of thing. If you haven’t done a lot of that, ask for help. Lawyers are are really we’re a pretty helpful group. We want to see everyone succeed because every big verdict that comes out helps us all. So don’t hesitate to ask for help from anyone.
Elizabeth Larrick (30:54.986)
Absolutely. Very good piece of advice for anyone, no matter where you are on the spectrum, whether you’ve just started out or you’ve been doing this for 40 years, a lot of the folks that I work with have the wherewithal that you are telling them, which is ask for help. Get an outside perspective because that will always make your cases better. Wonderful. Awesome. Well, thank you so much, Tony, again, for joining us.
Tony Edwards (31:13.941)
Exactly.
Elizabeth Larrick (31:18.602)
And for all of you listening, we will have this episode out with all of the contact information for Tony. If you have something Oklahoma, or like you said, maybe you just want to pick his brain and ask him questions about case framing, all his contact will be in the show notes.
Tony Edwards (31:31.778)
Thank you very much for having me.
Elizabeth Larrick (31:33.836)
You are welcome. That’s a wrap on today’s episode. Huge thank you to Tony Edwards for joining me. If this conversation got you thinking differently about how you’re framing cases early, that’s exactly the point. The contact information for Tony Edwards will be in the show notes if you want to reach out to him for questions. But don’t forget, case frame early and win more. Thank you again for listening. And until next time, keep on prepping to win.