Trial Strategy in Action: Timelines, Sequencing, and What Wins [Ep 167]

There is a crucial difference between timelines and sequences, and if you want jurors to see your case as plainly as you see it, you need to pay close attention.

Today we explore not just how timelines help jurors understand the case quickly, but why that is: the psychology and brain science behind retaining information. Timelines are a curated visual picture of the case, sequencing is about the order of presenting evidence.

Similar, yet each with their own distinct psychologies.

I know, not all lawyers use timelines, but they can be very effective, and focus groups help you recognize and fine tune what is most likely to register with juries. We want to make things as clear as possible for the jury, so don’t lose your jury because you’re jumping around the timeline. Logic, clarity and chronology that are structured and presented well can make all the difference.

If you want to test your timeline and sequencing presentation on a focus group, book a free call with me.

In this episode, we cover:

  • How cognitive science shows that the first information is often assumed to be the first event.
  • Why sequencing is essential for guiding jurors to a conclusion.
  • How focus groups can help identify key events for timelines.
  • Why overloading jurors with information can lead to confusion and undermine your case.
  • Both timelines and sequencing are necessary for effective persuasion.

Further links and references from this episode:

Episode 158: Trial Strategy v. Trial Tactics

New Blog post: Which Virtual Focus Group does Your Case Need?

You can also watch today’s episode on my YouTube Channel:
Trial Strategy in Action: Timelines, Sequencing, and What Wins [Ep 167]

Don’t miss out on the Trial Lawyer Prep Newsletter that is delivered right to your email with extra tips and ‘how to’ information. Join the newsletter here:

Deposition Clips or Live Witness: The Call That Won the Case [Ep 166]

Five days before trial, a team chose to play defense witness deposition clips, instead of calling the witnesses live.

Instinct tells us, training tells us: do it live. Live is better. Live is more persuasive. Live is much more catchy for cross exam. Video puts people to sleep.

However, what I walk you through today really boils this down to a primacy question, or in other words, first impressions. In the case above, focus group data showed that clips were having far more impact in setting the stage, and locking in that first impression. So the team pivoted, and the trial took on an entirely new phase.

Playing short clips produced visible juror annoyance, and later live testimony only confirmed the negative impression, contributing to a verdict of over $7 million.

The choice between clips and live testimony should be data-driven. It could mean using either clips or live witnesses, but the principle is this: don’t just assume that live is better.

If you’ve got a trial coming up and a decision you’re wrestling with, and you want to test it out to find the first impression, book a free call with me:

https://www.calendly.com/elizabethlarrick

In this episode, we cover:

  • How primacy affects jurors’ first impressions significantly.
  • Why live witnesses are traditionally seen as more persuasive.
  • Understanding juror perception is key to trial success, and focus groups help guide that understanding.
  • Testing witness credibility through focus groups is essential.
  • Why the first impression of a witness is hard to change once set.

Don’t miss out on the Trial Lawyer Prep Newsletter that is delivered right to your email with extra tips and ‘how to’ information. Join the newsletter here:

Using AI in Trial Prep and the Courtroom with Matthew Fornaro [Ep 165]

AI has hit the mainstream, and not just in everyday life, but in trial law and legal prep.

The days of startups and experimental software have quickly evolved to comprehensive, through and reliable AI-based programs, used by countless law firms and lawyers every day.

As a result, it feels like we are racing to keep up. To jump on the bandwagon before it’s too late, yet making sure you’re using AI in accurate, and ethical, ways.

Matthew Fornaro is a South Florida business litigator, with over 20 years of courtroom experience and a long track record of representing small businesses, entrepreneurs and startups in commercial litigation, contract disputes and arbitration. But what brings him to Trial Lawyer Prep today is his insight on using AI in trial prep and the courtroom.

Matthew has dedicated his time to learning different AI programs, applying them to different types of cases, and analysing the results. He is thus well-placed to detail with us specific platforms and strategies for using AI, that enhance trial outcomes.

AI serves as a collaborative tool, not a replacement for human judgment. But knowing how to integrate it into your practice can pay huge dividends in time, accuracy, the effectiveness of response and rebuttal, and ultimately: better results for you and your clients.

In this episode, we cover:

  • The various aspects of AI application, including document review, jury instructions, and cross-examination
  • AI helps lawyers distil complex cases into understandable narratives
  • Using AI responsibly requires fact-checking and ethical considerations
  • How to make sure you are choosing software that is conceptually proven, not just theoretical (looks good on paper)
  • How AI can democratize access to legal resources for smaller firms.

Learn more about my guest Matthew Fornaro:

Have a trial or mediation coming up and want to test with a focus group? Book a free consultation call with Elizabeth to learn more:

Don’t miss out on the Trial Lawyer Prep Newsletter that is delivered right to your email with extra tips and ‘how to’ information. Join the newsletter here:

Episode Transcript

Elizabeth Larrick (00:00.578)

For this brand new episode of Trial Lawyer Prep, I am thrilled to introduce my guest, Matthew Fornaro. Matthew is a South Florida business litigator with over 20 years of courtroom experience and a long track record of representing small businesses, entrepreneurs, and startups in commercial litigation, contract disputes, and arbitration. But what brings him to the show today is something a little different.

Matthew has become one of the foremost voices on using AI in trial practice and litigation. In this conversation, he is going to walk us through how he has used AI across multiple recent trials with success: the platform he relies on, how he prompts them, how he uses it in trial, and how to prepare for it, plus his rules for using AI responsibly and ethically.

Whether you’re curious or skeptical, this is an episode for you to walk away with a practical framework. Let’s get to it. Hello, and welcome to Trial Lawyer Prep. I’m your host, Elizabeth Larrick, and we have an AI specialist with us today. I would love to welcome Matthew Fornero to the show, and he is going to talk to us about a recent trial where he used AI. So welcome to the show, Matthew.

Matthew Fornaro (01:23.838)

Elizabeth, thanks for having me.

Elizabeth Larrick (01:25.494)

Of course. I mean, I have to tell you, you have a wonderful reputation on podcasts and we’re gonna send a lot of links out when we broadcast this episode because you are pretty good at what you do. So give us a little interview, a little preview, a little background.

Matthew Fornaro (01:44.591)

Sure. So hello everyone. It’s me, Matthew Fennero. I am an attorney in Florida. I’ve been an attorney for 23 years. I’m licensed in Florida, DC, and New York, and I predominantly practice 90%.

commercial litigation and 10% transactional. I represent small businesses, entrepreneurs, and startups regarding their legal needs, mostly litigation, arbitration, alternative dispute resolution, all that stuff. So I do a ton of litigation. I was in court all day today on Zoom.

And I think once on teams. So it depends on which fiefdom you’re in. Some of them use different programs. But you know, that’s what I do. I like litigation. You know, I love the punishment. I love the the non sequitur nature of it and how it doesn’t make sense and how there’s, you know, no real winners or losers, just you know, whatever in litigation. So that’s what I do, and I’m glad to talk about some interesting trial stuff. And like you said, I’m a big

proponent for the responsible and ethical use of AI, which a lot of people just use AI and don’t do it that way. And a lot of people got in trouble, particularly in our profession. So I always make sure. Yeah. So I always make sure, you know, I fact source check, side check everything I put out before I do it. But, you know, I love the AI. I increasingly use it more and more and I use it more and more in my legal practice. And I use it more and more in my trial practice. And the last

I know we’ve talked offline, you know, previously. The last few trials I’ve essentially done with the assistance of multiple AI platforms as far as from you know long term initial getting ready, whatever, to actual like the trial is happening. I need to do stuff in a reactionary phase. So happy to talk about it in depth. We can go through it or whatever you want to do.

Elizabeth Larrick (03:43.244)

Yeah, I think that is for our audience here. We are mostly trial lawyers, personal injury, employment law, but I know lawyers, trial lawyers are very curious about using AI in new ways. We’ve heard about ways to use it for medical summaries and writing demands, but I think the way that you are using it for trial is different than what we’ve heard before. So I know I’m curious and the audience is curious to hear more. So

Tell me just a little bit about kind of that decision to use AI with an upcoming trial.

Matthew Fornaro (04:17.121)

Sure. So, you know, I do, you know, I don’t do personal injury. I don’t do like cool medical malpractice stuff. There’s not a lot of cool visual stuff going on. I just do, you know, commercial litigation, like breach of contract, fraud, you owe me money, I owe you money, you know, we’re having a business divorce, that kind of thing. So which

Elizabeth Larrick (04:37.272)

Which is very exciting by the way. I’ve done a few of those and trust me, they can be way more exciting than personal injury. Okay.

Matthew Fornaro (04:43.256)

Yeah, there they’re all kinds of both sides. Yeah, it’s all kinds of bad interpersonal conflicts between people and things like that. You know, like like other litigation, but it’s not like, you know, I don’t have like a lot of you know, more and more there’s more like visual stuff and there’s more like charts and

demonstrative aids and whatever because that’s just how courtrooms are now, you know, in modern courtrooms. They, you know, that’s everyone’s looking for visuals, particularly when it’s like a jury trial, no matter how lame your trial is, no matter how the, you know, where’s the flashing lights in the candy? Where can I look? So they’re always looking for that. So, you know, I’m not as heavily dependent on cool, like, you know, here’s a picture of this wound or, you know, or this accident reconstruction or stuff, but there’s a lot of AI stuff that just does that.

But you know, like what I do with my AI in doing my trial preparation, again, we spoke again offline. I have another trial coming up, allegedly 10-day jury trial starting on Monday. But like I said, I’m kind of like the second chair, so I’m not sweating it as much as the dude who’s doing the serious, but I am gonna, you know, obviously do stuff in gear up. But, you know, I use a mix of different AI platforms just in my regular legal practice, and then I, you know, obviously refine and

do a little bit more when I get ready for trial. And what I basically do is, you know, I use the AI as like a supplement to what I’m doing and kind of have it be like a general document arranger, a general like second set of eyes. And I make sure that I have all my stuff that I do, like I’ve been doing for, you know, 20 years before I ever started using AI as an attorney of like, okay, I’m the plaintiff or I’m the defendant. Here’s my claims. Here’s my

Defenses, here’s the elements I need to prove. Here’s the elements that they need to prove. So the AI just helps me like do that in a much shorter time period and make sure that like I have a second set of eyes to make sure that everything that I’ve been doing last 20 years is like good and effective and it saves a lot of time and it makes things a lot more accurate or whatever. So like I have specific legal AI platforms that I have. Like I have

Matthew Fornaro (07:01.716)

West Co Council, I have Cleo’s Vincent, I have Open Case, and then I have like general large language model like ChatGPT, and then I have Galaxy.ai, which is a huge engine that has 6,000 different AI programs built into it. So I use all that as like a schmorkesborg of like putting things together, assembling things, doing whatever, and basically like putting together the nucleus of my

trial and then building from there. So I have like all my pleadings. I have all my proposed exhibits. I have, you know, all my proposed questions. I have all like what are the elements? I have what are the facts. I have all the depositions. I have all the discovery responses. I have all that stuff. And basically, you know, I review it to make sure I’m familiar with it and whatever. And then instead of taking, you know, an insane amount of time like I used to of having to type everything out or do whatever

I have the AI assist me, particularly the legal AI stuff, assist me in putting together, like, okay, I have a breach of contract case. I have fraud. I have like some statutory stuff, whatever. And then the AI and I like collaborate on putting together, like, okay, well, here’s your witness list. Here’s all your witnesses. Who do you want to call first? What do you want them to stay? What do you want

you know, them not to say. And just running all that through the AI helps you like essentially assemble your trial as far as you obviously are in charge, you know, you’re the final say, but you take all your exhibits, you, you know, consult with the AI and figure out, okay, what’s the best order to come up with my exhibits? How should I do my exhibits? My witnesses, what’s the best order for my witnesses? You know, you just collaborate back and forth with the AI, making sure that your prompts are

very specific and very good because the AI is only as good as the prompts you put into it. And you gotta make sure you s even for the legal specific stuff, you have to set everything up, not perfectly, but you have to make sure that you, you know, put the fence around what you’re doing. So like I am 20 plus year business law attorney Matthew Fennero, who has however much experience doing whatever, this is a state court

Matthew Fornaro (09:17.388)

case in Broward County, Florida in front of this judge. And then basically you go back and forth and refine it till you come up with your plan. And then basically you take your plan and then keep refining it. But you’re not relying totally on it, but you’re using it for insight and you know like a truly objective second set of eyes or virtual eyes, whatever. And as things develop in the trial and if you want to change something or do something, you update your AI prompts or whatever. And you’d be like,

This witness got on the stand and was a disaster, and now I have to rehabilitate him or her and come up with whatever. How do I do that? And basically, you know, it’s just a supplement to your trial preparation, your trial execution, whatever. And it’s like a second set of eyes. It’s like a second chair, third chair, whatever you want, where you know, you don’t rely on solely what the AI says, you use it as an augmentation to your own abilities and your own whatever.

As long as you know you check over it, make sure you do things, makes the trial so much easier because just things that you would have to think about and, you know, second guess yourself or whatever doesn’t exist anymore because it’s all taken care of. And then, okay, that’s a good plan. I wish I would have thought of that. And then you just go with it.

Elizabeth Larrick (10:36.598)

So my question is, are you feeding it your strategy and your case themes and are you teaching it about storytelling when you’re thinking through ’cause I get it, you know, putting exhibits in order, read this depot, like, you know, come up with some questions, but are you feeding it really kind of your actual like lawyer pre persuasion kind of stuff?

Matthew Fornaro (11:01.054)

I kind of I don’t want to say save that for myself, but like I put some of that in there. But like I said, I try to keep it as black and white and kind of dry as possible where I just wanted to do pure ministerial work.

Elizabeth Larrick (11:13.644)

What I’m thinking more about is so for example, just tried a case with a large group of trial lawyers and we had a a a a a case theme that went through every witness and we echoed some questions. So that’s what I’m kinda asking about is thinking.

Matthew Fornaro (11:29.592)

Like if I have like an overriding plan or whatever, like I’ll be like ultimately here’s what we’re gonna do. And then obviously I put that as part of my massive, you know, filibuster prompt before I start doing anything as far as whatever. But yeah, I put that some of that in there. But most of like the hum you know, like the humanity, you know, whatever theme development or whatever, I still leave that for the human to do as opposed to the AI to do. But yeah, I collaborate with it a little bit to do that.

Elizabeth Larrick (11:59.224)

Sure. And also just thinking through kind of basics of like brain science. Like, okay, look, you think about the primacy, what’s the first thing that’s most important to say or the sequencing of this? So can you do you normally like to use AI to do like that kind of brain science stuff?

Matthew Fornaro (12:12.62)

Yeah. Like what should we do first, second, third, how should we develop this and do whatever? So yeah, it’s really helpful because, you know, I may be wrong, it may be wrong, but if we collaborate together, we’ll at least come up with a plan that I probably won’t have thought of or it, you know, is incapable or whatever of thinking of without human assistance and then put it together and it’s probably a successful combo.

Elizabeth Larrick (12:36.632)

So one of things you said that kind of like was a light bulb moment for me was thinking through like if I was gonna get you up to speed on the trial that we’re about to do, I would have to spend so much time getting you up to speed and then getting you to ask me questions and like to get, you know, kind of the brainstorming going. So do you feel like it really helps speed up that kind of a little bit of that creative process that you would have with a second chair or an associate?

Matthew Fornaro (13:01.42)

Yeah, because you’re essentially telling like the inside story of the case to a third second party or third party, whatever you want to call it. So yeah, it facilitates you better understanding your own case and how you’re gonna present it to an objective third party because you’re presenting it to a subjective third party to begin with. And then you figure out how you’re gonna be like, okay, well here’s this and that and that.

But it facil I mean, it’s just it facilitates communication with anyone because it makes you have to really distill down what you’re doing and whatever, instead of like, you know, being totally unorganized or, you know, partially organized or whatever, it really helps you focus and figure out what’s important and how to tamp down on what it is you need to do at trial.

Elizabeth Larrick (13:52.224)

Awesome. Well let’s talk then about specifics because I know that’s gonna be helpful for most people to hear. Maybe something specific that you were able to do or use in a recent trial.

Matthew Fornaro (14:03.64)

Sure. So I had the LLC divorce case, all right, that I origin like probably my first AI heavily used trial that I did. So I represented the defendant in a LLC divorce case, basically, where it was two members of an LLC splitting up, doing whatever, and we were the defendant. We, you know, won quote unquote, you know, we prevailed, we got a jury verdict in our favor where they got zero and

And then under the operating agreement and under a proposal for settlement, which is a statutory thing in Florida, I got our attorney’s fees and our calls. So the AI helped me, cause there were really like nerdy like accounting documents and like spreadsheets and stuff. The AI really helped me go through all that information from a document review standpoint to begin with and know like

Okay, this is what my guy was responsible for. This is what the other guy was responsible for. And it really saved me a lot of time from having to either do all that stuff myself or pay for like a outsource doc review or something like that. So it got, you know, those thousands of documents like good and ready to go. So I knew essentially what was in there. So then that kind of proved our defenses because

They were trying to say, like, you didn’t keep corporate formalities, you didn’t do anything. And I’m like, okay, well, here’s five thousand pages of, you know, responsibility of who did what or whatever, and then I had it all indexed and everything, so I could just pull up whatever and be like, This account goes here, this account goes here, this account goes here. That was effective because it was the jury, and you know, the jury’s like, you know, there’s this

thick a piece of like whatever. Obviously, if the other guy’s saying they don’t do anything right, what’s all this paper for or whatever? So then that was a huge exhibit or whatever. And then again, I didn’t have to go through the nitty-girdy or whatever. The AI helped, you know, collate and put it all together and break down specifically what was in there. So that was a pretty effective tool. And then obviously, you know, also just as far as like the AI helped me figure out like what order I wanted to put my witnesses

Matthew Fornaro (16:18.692)

how I wanted to impeach their witnesses, you know, some ideas as far as what their causes of action were, what my defenses were, and just kind of, you know, it really helped put together a a good outline and game plan for how to run the trial. So, you know, I mean it’s just like I said, it’s a great supplement to really put together everything in focus and just go execute at trial at a high level because a lot of the things that you second guess on, a lot of the things that you did I overlook this or whatever?

The AI kind of fills in the gaps and helps you make sure that you don’t overlook everything, particularly if you don’t have a large trial team or a large, you know, budget to do whatever. I mean, it’s like a great democratizer equalizer.

Elizabeth Larrick (17:00.846)

Well let’s break it down a little bit. So document review is something that every lawyer has to do, whether it’s medical records or emails or business records. So tell me a little bit about the pro the platform that you used and how confident you felt in in that it was actually like it wasn’t missing anything in the documents.

Matthew Fornaro (17:20.705)

Yeah, so the you know, it’s interesting because the whole world of like legal AI stuff really started with like document review and document stuff. And there’s like a lot of established huge document companies and you know, things that have been around for a long time. So like West, who’s you know the premier publisher along with Lexus.

has in their co-council they’ve developed a whole document review protocol and a whole document review thing that you don’t need the specialized document software anymore because this does it so like the West Council does it just is good in my opinion because I’ve seen some of that stuff like the synchrony and all that other stuff. It you know fact checks everything it verifies everything and then obviously you fact check it and proof check it against what you did anyways to make sure it’s all there but

No, it’s just it’s a great platform, a great time saver, a great resource saver.

Elizabeth Larrick (18:17.482)

So what I hear you saying is that’s the main one you depend on when you’re doing some of this trial preparation for jury instructions and that kind of stuff?

Matthew Fornaro (18:25.836)

Yeah, because it’s also not a specific large language model. It is a closed universe of only West material and whatever you give it. So it’s not gonna do all these crazy things like hallucinate things. It’s not gonna make up citations, it’s not gonna tell you what the law in New Zealand is by accident or anything like that. It’s totally focused only on the world of West publishing. So the legal research

portion is totally closed off, walled off, it can’t hallucinate, it doesn’t do anything. And then the fact portion is only what you give it. It doesn’t go and find facts or hallucinate facts anywhere else or whatever. It only does what you tell it to do and it only looks at what you give it to look at. The biggest knock on like large language models like you know ChatGPT or whatever else thing you’re using, whether it’s Google or

Gemini or you know anything else is that it wanders off into you know Reddit and all you know four square and crazy things and draws information from outside of a defined set of parameters. And that’s how you get you know hallucinated case law, that’s how you get hallucinated facts or whatever. If that doesn’t exist in the universe you’re operating in, then the chances of it happening are microscopic.

Could still happen. Not so

Elizabeth Larrick (19:53.664)

I think more what I was thinking of is there are a lot of times that have closed systems where you feed them a large amount of documents and they still don’t seem to get all the things that are in the documents. So that’s why I’m trying to say you it sounds to me like you feel really confident about West Co. Council that when you’re feeding in those five thousand documents for that trial and that you felt really confident that again, ’cause you’ve used it probably so much that it didn’t miss anything in those documents.

Matthew Fornaro (20:21.026)

Yeah, no, I’m one hundred percent confident in like a document review thing. I know it’s not gonna miss those documents. Again, I still fact check, proof check, and make sure it went through all that stuff. You know, I’m not like just blindly like, West, whatever you say is you know, like, you know, whatever West said, I’m going down with part. No, but as a supplement, instead of me looking at the stuff and then giving it to doc review attorneys or associates or whatever to go through as

The second set of eyes to go through it, collate it, and whatever, it has not failed me yet. And based on the way that it’s programmed and the universe it operates in, I don’t foresee it happening, but it can. And again, I’m not, that’s why I’m not, you know, like I said, I just don’t blindly march in there. I still do the legwork and then, you know, save a lot of time on the redundancy with using the AI.

Elizabeth Larrick (21:18.956)

Gotcha, gotcha. Okay, awesome. Well you talked about doc review. you talked a little about jury instructions. So I’m really curious about kind of how you’re doing that because I know there are some of us who we sometimes face this question about like how many questions on our jury, you know, verdict form and and which instructions go in. So walk us through a little bit about kinda how you’re doing that jury instruction.

Matthew Fornaro (21:41.144)

Sure. So for like state court in Florida, like, you know, we have our Florida Supreme Court approved jury instructions for every single kind of law you can imagine. You know, you have your general civil, like, you know, your general civil law which encompasses everything. And then you have like the business specific ones, which are like breach of contract, the undress enrichment.

You know, you have your personal injury specific ones, your medical malpractice specific ones. So a lot of it’s already covered and it’s just using the language that’s in there. But then there’s special things where there’s certain affirmative defenses that aren’t, you know, there’s no uniform jury instruction for that, or there’s no uniform jury instruction for like a really whacked out, multi-faceted, contingent fact pattern or something like that.

So the AI, you know, helps you because it draws straight from the fact sources and then you tell it like, well, I have a unique circumstance because, you know, I have this going on or whatever, and then it’ll help you come up with ideas of like, Okay, well, here’s some possible jury instructions to look at regarding your unique circumstances where you can’t use uniform jury instructions. And then basically you take its work product and then you use your own skill and

you know, whatever it is you have and then put it together and then you come up with your proposed instructions, which of course the other side objects to. And then the court decides what’s you know, what it’s gonna use as far as the jury instructions based on things that aren’t standard uniform jury instructions. But it helps being able to formulate that stuff where as opposed to in the past, you know

Well, let me go pull a case that says what, you know, the DEFTA claim is in Florida or whatever. And then instead of being like, Well, let me put together the elements, whatever, it just helps you integrate it and deal with a lot of history anymore. And then as far as the verdict form, you put together your ideas as far as the verdict form, like, here’s what I want it to do, and then it’ll help you look at different alternatives and different options as far as like, Well, I don’t think to have it be like

Matthew Fornaro (23:50.498)

you know, and or go down to this box and or get another st that’s a pretty good idea. And then obviously the other side objects to it and then the judge goes through it and then you get your formulated jury instruction and your formulated verdict form, but it gives you alternatives and ideas that you may not have thought of yourself or permutations of things where it’s like various shades of gray versus black and white and it helps fill that in.

Elizabeth Larrick (24:16.398)

Awesome. I’m really curious, Matthew, how you’re using it in trial for like cross-examination. Tell us a little bit about that.

Matthew Fornaro (24:26.232)

Sure. It helps you come up with, you know, you review your discovery responses, your depositions, you see where people tripped up and did stuff or whatever, and you feed all your questions and all your stuff into it. And then you’d be like, okay, well, there are any gaps, anything, you know, I should be looking at, or any cool stuff, or anything you can think of based on here’s what they’re alleging and here’s what they need to prove and here’s the questions I have. And then using it during trial if things happen, like I said.

You have it set up where you have your whole, you know, your whole schema of your trial in the prompt or whatever and in the working box or whatever you want to call it. And then as things happen or whatever, you just update it and you’d be like, you know, my client admitted, you know, he did whatever. Crazy and then how do I rebut that? And then, you know, it’ll give you ideas and then you just use it combined with your own skill and knowledge and then, you know, you go from there.

Elizabeth Larrick (25:26.034)

So let’s those are kind of two separate things. So let me just ask for the creating of cross exam questions, that kind of thing, what kind of platforms are you using to help kind of do that?

Matthew Fornaro (25:36.64)

So I use, like I said, I use the co-council, I use the Cleo Vincent, and then I kind of run it through a large language model as like a quarterback to take the information of my questions, my stuff, the stuff I came up with, the stuff that my specialized AI came up with, the stuff that my other specialized AI came up with, and then basically I have it coalesce it into.

A you know working model of okay, well, here’s everything together in a cohesive fashion that doesn’t be redundant or stupid and doesn’t you know make you bored or something like that in a in a not an entertaining but in a didactic fashion that goes from point A to point C that matches like you know your theme of your case, your what you need to prove, what they need to prove, whatever. And then basically it, you know.

it synthesizes it into a pretty good final version where obviously you take it, you go over it, you do the tweaks yourself, but it takes all of the base information that you get from all the various sources and puts it together into a pretty good, almost final product for you to use.

Elizabeth Larrick (26:53.324)

And then what are you using in trial?

Matthew Fornaro (26:56.416)

So in trial, I use depending on what I do, I have the Galaxy AI, which I said is like a huge repository of like 6,000 different, it’s up to almost 6,000. That was 3,000 when I started. It’s got 6,000 different AI programs in it. So there’s like literally 100 specific AI legal programs that are in Galaxy AI. So for in trial for

graphic presentation or for certain things or whatever. Great platform because there’s very specific things to do like slideshow presentations, to do PDF presentations, JPEG presentations, to do video, to do whatever. It’s all built in there versus, you know, you going and buying like 10 different apps or trial apps to do it. It’s all in there. So it makes a good visual presentation, makes a good effective showing in trial.

Elizabeth Larrick (27:55.766)

And and for the one though that’s helping you, like if you’re on a cross exam or you’re gonna have to rehab somebody, which one is that that you’re feeding information and getting output? Is that still co counsel? Okay, gotcha. Gotcha.

Matthew Fornaro (28:05.826)

Yeah, that’s still co council. Actually, awesome. Council is like if you were if you know, if the Titanic’s going down and we can only save one thing on the ship, grab the co council and go overboard.

No, it’s just it was the thing with co council is that it was it’s an in you know, the again I’ve not paid I I pay, I don’t get paid by them. So they were innovators in this space and they existed for you know, like over the going back like before the pandemic, they were their own company and then West like bought them because West was messing around with AI and they’re like, Well, let’s buy co council.

And so what they did was they took a very good program and then integrated it into all of West’s knowledge. And so that’s why, in my opinion, it’s the best legal AI platform there is, because West, I always have liked better than Lexus because there’s more in West as far as source material, legal material, whatever, because West has more publishing, more secondary sources and whatever, but that’s a whole

like law school like gang thing where like you’re either team lexus or team less, whatever. so it’s really effective and it really works and it’s really helped me in my not just my trial practice but my legal practice. And then, you know, as I become more versed in AI and learning how to use different AI platforms, I’ve integrated more stuff into make it a more cohesive package, a more

like safety protocols, all the stuff that’s in there to make sure that I’m not just like I said, blindly like West, whatever you say, you know, I’m not blindly going down with the ship. I make sure that it’s all redundant, fact checked and everything like that. So

Elizabeth Larrick (29:54.634)

Awesome. Okay, so I have a couple of like my my consulting brain is like let me ask you these questions. So okay, so do you ever use it? I know some people will play and literally practice jury selection with with AI. Have you ever practiced your jury selection with AI?

Matthew Fornaro (30:11.788)

Yeah, I use like I’ll use like chat for that for like a general perspective and I’ll just give it like a whole thing. And it’s interesting because, you know, I’m a big LinkedIn troll. So I love LinkedIn. I hang out on LinkedIn all day long. And you know, I still for whatever reason still like Facebook. And like I said, all I do is I get hit with ads twenty-four-seven on all my social media for law stuff and for AI stuff. And it’s interesting because there’s probably half a dozen

Jury picking slash what will a jury do AI platforms out there. I just use the general models to try to figure out, you know, some ideas or whatever, but there’s like actual AI models out there who it’ll be like, we’ll do a full simulated jury for you. And I’m like, How the hell does the AI do the full simulated jury? Like, I don’t know.

But, you know, or they’ll do like the full simulated like Void dire or like the whole thing where like that’s the whole AI program that’s all it does. So, you know, it’s very interesting. I’m not up to that point yet of using like such a very niche specialized thing for that, but I’ll use like the large language model and just kind of mess around with it a little bit to like, what do you think about this or you know, that kind of thing.

Elizabeth Larrick (31:27.554)

Gotcha. And that was gonna be my next question. There are so many AI jury simulation models that are out there and it sounds to me like you haven’t tried any of them just yet.

Matthew Fornaro (31:39.272)

No, I haven’t because I think that a lot of that is like more for like a certain type of litigation versus like commercial litigation. Like, you know, like I think the AI jury model, whatever, is probably more conducive to like a injury case or like a medical malpractice case where it’s like I deal a lot with, you know, not just liquidated damages, but damages that have like quantification or qualification that we can put on like

What is my breach of contract worth or what is my whatever worth? Where like we don’t really have to get that speculative or whatever versus like, you know, I lost a limb. What price do you put on that? Or like, you know, I’m blind, you know, some crazy thing or whatever or whatever, where you can’t like quantify damages as easy. So I think that those AIs or those AI programs are probably more conducive to that than they are for like a straight like well, it’s a liquidated sum, or it’s a you know, that kind of thing.

Elizabeth Larrick (32:36.024)

Sure, sure. But from a so let’s let’s take damages off the table and just from a persuasion and strategy kind of a thing, would you ever consider using one of the AI jury simulators? Yeah.

Matthew Fornaro (32:46.816)

I would. Yeah. The more you know, the more I see some like I don’t want to say like critical science on it, but the more I see like some verified stuff on it, I would. I’m talking about various programs that I’ve used successfully, whatever. Okay. I haven’t seen a lot of people talking about the virtual jury AI stuff yet in an objective fashion. When I do, maybe I’ll go after it then, but

You know, I see them trying to push and sell me a lot of that stuff, but I don’t see like, you know, we’re on, you know, Elizabeth’s podcast talking about, whoa, my AI jury selection did one hundred percent accuracy and you nailed it one hundred percent right down to the penny. So once we get to that position, yeah, probably I’ll use it.

Elizabeth Larrick (33:33.526)

Yeah. Then I was gonna say, so there’s a lot of people or a lot of lawyers I should say who you’re just getting started out and you’re bombarded with all the AI options. You’ve done a lot of vetting already. So what are some questions or things that if people are starting out using AI they should look at or what are kind of some vetting things that they should pay attention to?

Matthew Fornaro (33:55.126)

If you’re just getting into AI or you kind of just dabble in it and you don’t really I mean, you’re gonna drown just in the information you’re hit with of not knowing what to do or whatever. So I mean, you wanna look at stuff that actually has you know, I understand there’s innovative stuff and there’s new stuff, you gotta get going or whatever, but look at something that at least I don’t want to say has a track record, but at least is viable and is proven or conceptually proven. So a lot of the stuff out there is like really theoretical or whatever.

You gotta make sure, you know, you always need a large language model as part of your AI package. I use Chat GPT. A lot of people are switching to Claude or Gemini or whatever. I’m fine with Chat GPT. It’s not broke. I’m pretty good at using it at this point in time. I’ve checked out Claude. There’s a lot of people who are because Claude’s really trying to push itself in the legal industry because there’s a lot of like specialization or whatever, which like I’m like, okay.

so you know, you always have a large language model, and then for attorneys like a legal focused AI, where you can have more than one. I mean, Lexus has its own AI program, West has its own AI program, Cleo has its own AI program, you know, then there’s other things like Vine, which is another AI program, there’s Harvey, which is another AI legal program, there’s

I forget the name of it. There’s another one that just came out that’s aimed at midsized law firms only. So there are Harvey is like the the large law firm like AI thing and like they’ve got a really great marketing department because a lot of large law firms have bought Harvey or whatever. So I mean, you know, you just gotta figure out what works for you. I mean, you know, someone may be watching your show and be like, What the hell is he talking about? Council, it’s terrible. Or, you know Well, right, CoCouncil is great. So

So I mean, figure out what works for you. I mean, what it’s just just just like anything else. What works for me may not work for you, or vice versa, but you gotta find what works. Right. And one of the things you have to do is make sure, you know, like you have the basic package and then your specialized stuff, and then your really specialized stuff. So like the really specialized stuff is like the really theoretical stuff that’s still like not necessarily road tested, proven stuff, like the jury stuff.

Matthew Fornaro (36:16.106)

So I’m not really there yet with that stuff. I’m at the definitely the large language generalized stuff, 100%. The semi specialized like legal platform stuff, yes. The very niche niche specialized like trial exhibit AI, stuff like that, not yet. But like I said, you can explore and try out and a lot of different AIs. It’s not that expensive.

Elizabeth Larrick (36:40.064)

Well and that’s what I was gonna say. I mean it’s kind of a total fall down the rabbit hole and like you could bump into all kinds of different kind of stuff. So I think what I hear you saying is look for a track record. If something is new and shiny, like take a double pause and see if like if this is ever gonna be

Matthew Fornaro (36:58.808)

Could be great or it could be terrible. You’ll never know. I mean I

Elizabeth Larrick (37:02.552)

Well, I think you’re saying look for a track record. Like you mentioned for you, Co Council is like you feel really confident, you know exactly where it came from. You know it has all the stuff that you trust with West. So that is something that you have easily recommend to people and have no problem and like you said, some of the other stuff you’d recommend here today. But new things are coming out. Test it, but you know, look for a track record.

Matthew Fornaro (37:26.104)

Yeah, you know, trust but verify. Trust but verify. But it’s true. I mean some of this new stuff will be great. It’s just, you know, you don’t wanna be the person who’s like the innovator. You don’t wanna be the Neil Armstrong on the moon of, you know, some new cutting edge AI during trial and then it cuts out and then all of a sudden you’re back in the stone age, you’re like, Where’s my easel? You know, what do I do? You gotta make sure you have a backup system in place just in case.

Elizabeth Larrick (37:28.649)

Yes.

Elizabeth Larrick (37:52.258)

Thank you so much. And thank you so much for joining the podcast. It has been so helpful. I know there are lots of people who are dabbling and we are all people who get inundated constantly with new emails for different AI programs for lawyers. So you have been so helpful. I’m gonna leave some links, but if people want to reach out to you to learn more, I know you are a wealth of knowledge when it comes to this AI and using it in your trials and legal practice. So where is the best place people could go to reach you?

Matthew Fornaro (38:21.24)

Sure. So just go to my website, which is fonarolegal dot com and then it’s got all my contact information. It’s got all my social media and it’s got all my blogs and stuff and videos about AI and attorneys in AI and attorneys making mistakes with AI and attorneys doing good things with AI. So if you have any questions or whatever, just feel free to email or call me.

Elizabeth Larrick (38:43.278)

Wonderful. If you are interested in hearing a little more, he has all of his podcast guest spots on his website as well. So if you want more, there is more on Matthew’s website, and we’ll put a link to that in the show notes. Thank you again so much for joining the podcast. What parting words would you tell to some trial lawyers who are maybe they’re just starting out, maybe they’re just dabbling with AI?

Matthew Fornaro (39:06.04)

You know, AI is great, but you gotta take ownership over it no matter what you’re using it for in any capacity. And it always starts and stops with you, you know, the Harry Truman buck stops here thing. So you can use it, just make sure you’re in control of it and you don’t blindly follow it. And it’ll do great things, it’ll save you time, it’ll do a lot of work. You just gotta find what works for you and use it correctly.

Elizabeth Larrick (39:28.972)

Wonderful. Awesome. Well again, thank you so much for joining the podcast. Thank you all for joining and listening in today. And until next time, keep on prepping.

3 Steps to Get Reliable Juror Feedback [Ep 164]

Running a good focus group is really a lot like conducting a good trial: Fundamentally, it’s about understanding people.

And you don’t need a psychology degree to do so. If you have an innate understanding for human behavior, relationships, biases and different means of communication, then you already have the instinct to make the most of your focus groups.

Today’s episode breaks down three key steps to be organized and prepared for your next group. Armed with these tools, you can then hit the ground running and really connect with juries and clients.

We cover:

  • Setting clear goals for focus group sessions
  • Developing a structured plan to ensure effective listening
  • Overcoming personal biases in focus group settings
  • Avoiding common pitfalls like overloading information and lack of organization
  • Conducting test runs to improve the quality of focus group feedback
  • Don’t assume that you’re a natural presenter; preparation is key
  • Make sure you’re listening more than speaking
  • Seeking help if you’re too biased to run a focus group

Set up a free consultation today: https://www.calendly.com/elizabethlarrick

You can also watch today’s episode on my YouTube Channel:

3 Steps to Get Reliable Juror Feedback [Ep 164]

Additional resources:

How to Do Your Own Virtual Focus Groups Part 2: Planning and Moderating

Don’t miss out on the Trial Lawyer Prep Newsletter that is delivered right to your email with extra tips and ‘how to’ information. Join the newsletter here:

Witness Prep Strategies That Embrace Brain Science [Ep. 163]

Heading into deposition prep, your clients are typically nervous, anxious, overwhelmed and lacking confidence.

They are most likely in a situation they have never found themselves in before, and undoubtedly the stakes feel very high.

But we need to get them to focus, to remember, to think and answer clearly, and to let go of their fear and uncertainty.

This episodes focuses on three clear, distinct strategies that also help you remember how to get the most out of your clients at this crucial juncture. Clients will feed off of not just your confidence, but your calm demeanor and encouragement.

Elevate your practice with these insights for building a strong foundation in witness preparation. We tap into some fascinating brain science to help us all understand not just what to do, but why our brains, and therefore our emotions, function the way they do.

In this episode, learn how:

  • Your working memory holds only three to five things at a time.
  • Fear can block rational thought and memory retention.
  • Using clear language and expectations supports and empowers clients.
  • Roadmaps help clients understand their roles in depositions.
  • Repetition is key to overcoming the forgetting curve.
  • Role-playing scenarios help your client feel comfortable and confident during deposition.

Links from this episode:

  • Learn more about Hermann Ebbinghaus’ Forgetting Curve (via growthengineering.co.uk)

You can also watch today’s episode on my YouTube Channel:

Improve Your Clients’ Memory and Confidence With These 3 Techniques [Ep 163]

Have a trial or mediation coming up and want to test with a focus group? Book a free consultation call with Elizabeth to learn more:

Don’t miss out on the Trial Lawyer Prep Newsletter that is delivered right to your email with extra tips and ‘how to’ information. Join the newsletter here:

Trial Lawyers and Time Management: Wisdom from Dina Cataldo [Ep 162]

We’re all busy trial lawyers and specialists, typically juggling multiple cases at once. 

Time management and organization is crucial, and we can’t allow ourselves to get overwhelmed, to risk impacting not just the case but our own health and well-being.

It’s worth taking the time to make sure your tasks and workflow are efficient, your calendar flows logically, and your habits are positive and healthy. Even just a few minutes’ pause for retrospection and meditation can make a huge difference.

And I’ve been right in the thick of it lately myself! As a trial consultant, I was getting two separate trials off the ground here recently, and so was devoting a lot of time to helping those trials get their opening statements, hit lists, and order of proof ready.

This week’s episode was one of the most popular of 2025, and features lawyer coach Dina Cataldo. Dina talks to us about the unique challenges lawyers face in managing their time effectively, the importance of mindset in overcoming overwhelm, and practical strategies for creating healthy routines. 

Dina reveals methods like “Sunday planning,” and setting time limits for tasks, to streamline workflow and improve efficiency. 

And we talk about the unique challenges female attorneys face, balancing demanding careers with personal responsibilities, and provide strategies to enhance daily productivity and instill confidence.

In this episode, learn how:

  • Lawyers need to treat themselves as humans, not robots. Implementing time management is key for anyone in the legal field.
  • Self-awareness is at the core of managing time and reducing stress.
  • Healthy habits, including nutrition, impact overall performance and help you get better results.
  • Creating a structured plan can alleviate trial-related stress.
  • You can avoid getting caught underestimating the time needed for tasks. Address internal resistance and developing a healthy relationship with time.

Links from this episode:


You can also watch today’s episode on my YouTube Channel:

Trial Lawyers and Time Management: Wisdom from Dina Cataldo [Ep 162]

Follow and Review:

We’d love for you to follow us if you haven’t yet. Click that purple ‘+’ in the top right corner of your Apple Podcasts app. We’d love it even more if you could drop a review or 5-star rating over on Apple Podcasts. Simply select “Ratings and Reviews” and “Write a Review” then a quick line with your favorite part of the episode. It only takes a second and it helps spread the word about the podcast.

Have a trial or mediation coming up and want to test with a focus group? Book a free consultation call with Elizabeth to learn more:

Don’t miss out on the Trial Lawyer Prep Newsletter that is delivered right to your email with extra tips and ‘how to’ information. Join the newsletter here:

The Hard Truth about Persuasion and the Lawyer Brain [Ep 161]

We know we live in an attention-deficit age, where attention spans and concentration levels are lower than ever.

It’s not just about social media though. These trends carry forward into every day life, including in the court room. We simply can’t assume that just because the jurors are there and present, that they will necessarily be paying as close attention as we expect. It’s human nature to start to drift away and think about something else when you’re not otherwise captured by a subject, and there is fascinating brain science that demonstrates why!

So today we look at ways to maximize your impact, grab hold of the narrative, choose the most effective facts and frame your arguments in a way that keeps jurors engaged and wanting more.

Even the judge will notice this approach! And will appreciate how you started with the hook.

In fact, you could say that regardless of the impact of social media doom-scrolling, understanding these persuasion techniques has been a winning strategy in courtrooms, and beyond, for generations.

So, get to the point, cut the small talk, lean into the hook and the best facts, and remember who you’re talking to: tailor your presentation so that it resonates with a juror’s brain.

Set up a free consultation today: https://www.calendly.com/elizabethlarrick

In this episode, learn how:

  • Mediation focus groups help assess case value and strategy.
  • Running focus groups early can provide critical insights.
  • Each focus group builds on the previous one for better results.
  • Timing is key; don’t wait until the last minute.
  • Lawyers should commit to at least one focus group per case.

Links from this episode:

You can also watch today’s episode on my YouTube Channel:
The Hard Truth about Persuasion and the Lawyer Brain [Ep 161]

Don’t miss out on the Trial Lawyer Prep Newsletter that is delivered right to your email with extra tips and ‘how to’ information. Join the newsletter here:

Transcript

Elizabeth Larrick (00:00.398)
Have you forgiven a presentation and then saw people be completely confused by things that you said? Or maybe you gave a statement in a hearing and then the judge completely misread what you said? Well, it’s totally possible that you’re using persuasion the wrong way.

Welcome to Trial Lawyer Prep, where you learn how to better connect with clients and juries. Gather strategies to help you with persuasion and learn how to use focus groups along the way. I’m your host, Elizabeth Larrick, and in this episode, we’re gonna give some hard truths about how persuasion can escape trial lawyers. All right, I deal with this subject nearly every day with my focus groups and helping my lawyers prepare to give the best possible presentations.

Well, what I have found is there are three very simple ways that lawyers can confuse and get persuasion kind of messed up. So I want to talk about those today. And I want to help you do a better job. And these are three very simple things that we can consciously look at and change going forward. Now

You will see they are very simple, but they are also things that we can do in our preparation to change and make our presentations more persuasive. And they are based on brain science. Okay, so it’s not this magic that we’re gonna slip in there that you’ve never heard of. Okay. These are things that work with our brains. They come from lots of different areas of brain science, but my experience comes from doing focus groups and mock jury’s for over 10 years.

And so these are things that I help lawyers with when we prepare for focus groups. So every month I do focus groups from one hour all the way to three hours, but we always work and prepare with our lawyers for their presentations to be as persuasive as possible or to avoid the pitfalls of confusion. And so that’s what we’re gonna talk about here today, are three very simple things that we do as lawyers that can confuse our audience.

Elizabeth Larrick (02:19.99)
Lead them down the wrong path or get them to completely turn off before we even get to the juicy stuff we need them to hear. So let’s get right on top of it. Our lawyer brains are not juror brains. We have been trained a very different way, and then we take that training and we work with it for years. And so we have patterns of thought that stick with us all the time and they work for us because.

That’s what we do all day is we try to take the facts and apply it to the law. And so our patterns of thought are very simple. And we sometimes assume that everyone around us has the same thought pattern. And that’s where it can get a little bit confusing or crossways. So our lawyer brain, what does that really actually mean? Well, that means most of the time our brains tell us I need to give all the facts to prove my case. I need to really explain.

All of these things that are going on for you to really understand what happened. And also, I assume you think like I do. Now I try to simplify all these things, which means number one, we love to fact it up. We just pile facts and facts and facts and facts. We investigate more to bring more facts and we just inundate our audiences with facts. Number two, we start off on the wrong foot.

I am not really sure where this actually begins, but pretty much every lawyer that I’ve dealt with has some training somewhere. And again, trust me, I was that person too, where we’re told how we start is that we talk about ourselves. All right. So we’re gonna talk about starting off on the wrong foot. And the last thing is we forget framework. People need framework. They need an outline. They need structure when we’re giving them presentations, a little something we typically forget.

So let’s talk about very specifically how does this show up? Well, our first topic facting it up. So I feel like when we have opening statements, we tend to just fill them with facts. And we bombard our brain. So what happens inside? We can only hold a few things in our short term memory, right? I believe it used to be five to seven. I think it’s more like three. And so we overwhelm the brain with facts.

Elizabeth Larrick (04:44.366)
And then jurors lose it. They can’t hold them all in our short-term memory, so they get lost. And they don’t actually know the priority either. So they don’t know which ones are very important, which ones are not. So they have to pick their own. And typically they’re not going to pick the same ones as you. And so we really want to do our job in limiting and prioritizing.

So that our audience doesn’t have to do it. They know what our priority is, and we’re not overwhelming them with a set of facts. I see this happen pretty often in focus groups where we try to do either an opening statement or we try to do just a neutral narrative of the case. And facts upon facts upon facts upon facts. And then sometimes they just get repeated again in the same fashion.

And again, that’s sometimes where we think we’re repeating is persuasive, but not if it’s just a bunch of facts. So that’s where one of the best things we can do to fix this habit is to look at our presentation. Let’s just take an opening. Look at our opening and count the number of facts that we have in there. And then realize do they need all these facts in opening? Now I’m not saying remove them and don’t let them bring them in the case. You obviously think they’re important.

You’re gonna have to prioritize those things, right? So you wanna limit your facts that obviously gives priority, but then you want to rank them and deliver them in a way that also prioritizes them, okay? For the attention span of our audience. Now, you could be doing a hearing, it’s the same thing. You want to look at what your facts are, limit them to the ones that are the most important because you know you’ve already written a brief, you’ve already put it all in there.

Now we’re trying to talk directly to our short term memory of our judge and what’s the most important thing they need to know right now in this moment. By doing that, right, we alleviate our brains. We get we we don’t we don’t cause confusion immediately. So let’s move to number two here, which would be starting on the wrong foot. So this plays into the concept of brain science of primacy, meaning the first thing we say is given priority. It’s it’s given

Elizabeth Larrick (07:01.132)
More memory space, it’s more likely to be remembered. And so what happens here is we start off introducing ourselves almost all the time, every time. Hi, thank you so much for being here. My name is Elizabeth Larrick. I represent the plaintiff, Bob Smith. Okay, great. But what have you done now with those first four, five, four seconds? Like you you lose them, right?

What we know so far about how our brains are right now, I would say, is we have eight seconds to grab the attention. And then you have a little, if you get it, then you get a little bit more time, a little more, like a little less than 40 seconds then to then get the engagement that you need to keep the attention. But if we’re using our the first seconds out of our mouths to talk about who I am, who my client is, you’re you’re gonna get to that. They’re already gonna know that. You don’t need to reintrodu introduce yourself, right? So that

Very quick eight seconds, we don’t want to start off on the wrong foot. We don’t want to lose our audience. We want to use that primacy for the best that we possibly can. So there’s a camp obviously out there that says start with the hook, an open statement. Start with the statistic. Start with the this is a simple case about boom boom boom, right? All of those are keying in on the

Persuasion that you gather with the first thing that you say. So primacy is so important. But we have to be very conscious about fixing this. Okay, so the fix it here on getting off on the wrong foot is because we are so ingrained, literally, we have to write it out, and either you need to read it or you need to memorize it so that you don’t slip back into that old habit of my name is Elizabeth, I represent the plane of Bob Smith.

Thank you so much for being here. My name is like though, but get to the point, okay? And so that’s where, you know, some people think, well, a little small talk is helpful. Think about a hearing, Elizabeth. That may I promise you, that judge is gonna really appreciate that the first thing that you said was the hook. The most important thing for them to hear. Right. So let’s not lose that beautiful gem of attention that we get in that first eight seconds and that concept of primacy, okay?

Elizabeth Larrick (09:28.086)
Let’s talk about setting up a virtual focus group for you. I run several every single month. And you can click the link in the show notes for a free consultation. Now, let’s move into our third one here. This is going to be a pretty nice and short episode for you, which is we forget framework. Again, this falls back into we have our lawyer brains, our patterns of thought, we do them every day. We take the intake, we put it to law, we apply it.

And it makes sense for us, but it does not make any sense for regular folks. So we have made it in our brains very easy to find connections with fact and law. But regular people do not. This is where you have to help them make the connections. This is where our framework is so important because brains love patterns. They love to find patterns.

They love to see patterns that makes it happy. this is easy. I understand this. And so that’s why when you see a lot of opening statement frameworks or even hearing, like having a hearing, you have there’s a framework for that argument. It is so important when we talk about jurors that we pick a framework they are familiar with. So there’s a great book by Cliff Atkinson about PowerPoints, and there’s also a great seminar.

put on by Mr. Mark Lanier, where he talks about these frameworks and he picks easy frameworks. It’s the A B C’s, it’s the seasons, fall, winter, spring, summer, right? wait, I that’s a pattern that I know. That wait, okay, good, right? Because when we are starting something, right? We’re starting our opening statement. Yes, we have our eight seconds and our primacy, but we also have curiosity.

We also have anticipation that comes with that. And when you begin, we want to give them a framework. I’m gonna understand this. I’m gonna, okay, great. But the other thing is they can see the connections that their brains need to be making with facts and law without you hitting, you know, it’s subtle, right? So let me just step back here and give you a good example.

Elizabeth Larrick (11:54.382)
So rules of the road, Rick Freeman, rules of the road, are great. But other things are not as easy to grasp as rules of the road. People know we drive, great, rules of the road. you’re speeding, that’s a violation. That’s simple, right? We can make that connection quickly. But other cases are a little more complicated. And so when you create these rules, safety rules, company rules, right? When you create rules that go with the case.

You need to help them make the connection with the violation. So that’s where you’ll have the rule and then the checklist for the rule that says, okay, trucking companies must hire qualified drivers. Okay, great. Oop, I like this rule, but now I I really am lost after that. Okay. Because again, they don’t know what all the the specific rules are. So then here’s the checklist. So how does a company hire what’s the checklist that they use?

Okay, well, number one would be: does the driver have a valid commercial driver’s license? Yes or no? whoa, that’s great. I got that. Check the box. So that’s where we’re making a simple framework, a checklist that helps them make the connections. So many times, what I see in focus groups, and what I see even in trial, is lawyers will bombard their audience.

with a lot of information and no framework. And when you can provide a very structured framework, here’s what you’re going to hear next. Here’s the checklist for this. Now, what does that allow you to do? You can then use the checklist with every witness. You can use it again in closing, right? So then we’re repeating our framework. Okay, it’s familiar to our brains. So it’s not unusual. We’re just now taking other facts and putting it and making those connections

Because we will assume as lawyers that they are making the connections and they’re not. If you’ve ever gone to trial and you lost, you know they didn’t make the connection. Okay. So we want to use frameworks. We want to work with the brain that loves these patterns and these familiar frameworks. So let’s back up and let’s talk again. We have talked about three things that we do as lawyers with our lawyers’ brains that can completely get

Elizabeth Larrick (14:14.41)
Our audience on the wrong track and that are just the opposite of persuasion. And number one is that we fact it up. We bombard with all the possible facts. All the facts to prove are one point, or all our facts to prove are three or four or five points, right? Limit it. Prioritize it. Keep it simple for them, right? You’re gonna give them the rest of it in trial. Don’t worry. Our second one is starting on the wrong foot, right? Where we lose our audiences with an

Eight seconds because we are talking about ourselves. We’re saying things that make no difference to the case, right? That’s why we start with a hook. That’s why we start with this is a simple case about blah blah blah. Or you start with a stat, right? That’s why primacy is so important when we are lawyers and we’re talking to a new audience, or even if you’re talking with a judge, right? Maybe a familiar audience. Don’t lose out on that very first thing. Start off on the right foot.

And lastly, we forget framework. We forget that regular people need help making the connections that we make so easily in our brains. And how do we do this overall? And again, it’s making the time right to prepare, go back and say, okay, where could I be losing people? Do I have a framework? How am I starting? Okay, let me not get off on the wrong foot. Let me write this out and read it verbatim. And then

Obviously, let me limit the facts here to the most important ones and then prioritize them for my audience because they won’t know. They won’t know how to prioritize it. I’ll help them out and do it for them. All right. I hope that this episode was helpful because listen, it’s the hard truth to know that sometimes our brains are working against us, but simple ways to fix it. Thank you so much for listening to Trial Lawyer Prep. Until next time, keep preparing to win.

The Three-Phase Focus Group Strategy Every Trial Lawyer Needs [Ep 160]

You’re not going to be one of those lawyers that only starts thinking about a focus group 30 days before the trial, right?

To make the most of the power and impact of focus groups, work backwards through this three-phase roadmap that helps you plan and prepare.

You will see, and feel, a remarkable difference in your confidence, arguments and ultimately, your case.

Why three phases?

This structure taps into the various stages of trial prep, and gives you focus groups that are appropriate and effective for the moment your case is in.

Whether it’s in Phase 1 (Discovery), Phase 2 (Settlement/Mediation), or Phase 3 (Trial), focus groups reflect juror attitudes, bias and weakness detection, theme and damages testing, witness credibility feedback, and help lawyers make better settlement-versus-trial decisions.

Work with me to fine-tune this strategy and ensure you’re getting the most out of your focus groups! 

Set up a free consultation today: https://www.calendly.com/elizabethlarrick

In this episode, learn how:

  • Mediation focus groups help assess case value and strategy.
  • Running focus groups early can provide critical insights.
  • Each focus group builds on the previous one for better results.
  • Timing is key; don’t wait until the last minute.
  • Lawyers should commit to at least one focus group per case.

I also talk in today’s episode about a common misconception we have on how decisions are made for mediation. There is a dedicated episode on this topic, Episode 142, which you can find here: 

Avoid This Mistake if You Plan to Use Focus Group Clips in Mediation [Ep 142]

You can also watch today’s episode on my YouTube Channel:
The Three-Phase Focus Group Strategy Every Trial Lawyer Needs [Ep 160]

Follow and Review:

We’d love for you to follow us if you haven’t yet. Click that purple ‘+’ in the top right corner of your Apple Podcasts app. We’d love it even more if you could drop a review or 5-star rating over on Apple Podcasts. Simply select “Ratings and Reviews” and “Write a Review” then a quick line with your favorite part of the episode. It only takes a second and it helps spread the word about the podcast.

Have a trial or mediation coming up and want to test with a focus group? Book a free consultation call with Elizabeth to learn more:

Don’t miss out on the Trial Lawyer Prep Newsletter that is delivered right to your email with extra tips and ‘how to’ information. Join the newsletter here:

REPLAY: Traditional Methods of Jury Selection are Broken with Sharif Gray [Ep 159]

The jury selection process is changing and evolving. Are you willing to be bold and confront jury selection challenges head-on?

This was a popular and very actionable conversation that I had with Sharif Gray last year, where we talked about what could be broken with your jury selection.

We looked at assumptions and stereotypes that are often made, and I think it’s a question worth returning to as we get deeper into 2026, when you may have trials coming up on the horizon.

It could be very useful to consider these suggestions and tips when you’re making important decisions on selecting, or deselecting, your jury members.

Sharif turns the tables on many standard approaches and perspectives, and suggests that instead, we take potential concerns and weaknesses and turn them to our advantage.

In so doing, you will demonstrate credibility, authenticity, trust and respect, for the potential jurors, the judge and even the defence.

“We’re there for fairness. So I’m looking for jurors who are going to do right by my client, but I’m also looking for jurors who are going to do right by the defense. Because it’s not justice if you’re  going to close your eyes and just vote for my side every day of the week.” – Sharif Gray.

Sharif is a trial lawyer based in Richmond, Virginia, and the host of the Courtroom Stories and Tactics podcast, where he and his guests do deep dives on topics like voir dire, jury selection, the role of the legal system, and one of my favorites: focus groups! I was honored to be a guest on Sharif’s show earlier this year.

In this episode, you will learn about:

  • Challenges in Traditional Jury Selection
  • Building Credibility with the Jury
  • Starting Jury Selection Right
  • Effective Communication Techniques
  • Building Credibility in the Courtroom
  • Handling Juror Bias and Concerns

Follow and Review:

We’d love for you to follow us if you haven’t yet. Click that purple ‘+’ in the top right corner of your Apple Podcasts app. We’d love it even more if you could drop a review or 5-star rating over on Apple Podcasts. Simply select “Ratings and Reviews” and “Write a Review” then a quick line with your favorite part of the episode. It only takes a second and it helps spread the word about the podcast.

Supporting Resources:

Guest Sharif Gray of Broughton Injury Law.

Find Broughton Injury Law here: graybroughton.com

Reach Sharif personally at RVA Trial Lawyers: rvatriallawyers.com

Listen to Courtroom Stories and Tactics, by RVA Trial Lawyers: rvatriallawyers.com/podcast/

Find my episode on Sharif’s podcast: Mastering Witness Preparation Method and Focus Groups | with Elizabeth Larrick (Trial Consultant)

The Voir Dire to Verdict training event is happening again! October 23, 2026. Click here for more info

Email Sharif: triallawyers@rvatriallawyers.com 

You can also watch this episode on YouTube here: Traditional Methods of Jury Selection are Broken! with Sharif Gray (replay) [Ep 159]

Trial Strategy v. Trial Tactics: Why Lawyers Confuse Them and What it Costs You [Ep 158]

Are you confident in knowing the difference between trial strategy and trial tactics?

Because ultimately the question is, does your jury understand what you’re doing?

Today, we’re looking at how to identify a clear strategy as the overarching theme that guides the trial, followed by the tactics to achieve that strategy.

There’s a risk of confusing the two, including wasted time and causing confusion for jurors. The best strategies combine preparation and flexibility when you’re in the courtroom.

And remember, focus groups can test strategies early in the trial preparation process, showing you where to refine those strategies early.

In this episode:

  • Confusing strategy and tactics can lead to juror confusion.
  • Tactics should be flexible and adaptable during trial.
  • Jurors expect consistency in case presentation.
  • Wasting time on tactics without a clear theme can cost cases.
  • Focus groups can help test and refine trial strategies early.


You can also watch this episode on my YouTube Channel:

Have a trial or mediation coming up and want to test with a focus group? Book a free consultation call with Elizabeth to learn more:

Don’t miss out on the Trial Lawyer Prep Newsletter that is delivered right to your email with extra tips and ‘how to’ information. Join the newsletter here:

Episode Transcript

Welcome to Trial Lawyer Prep, where you learn how to better connect with clients and juries, gather up strategies to be persuasive, and how to use focus groups along the way. I’m your host, Elizabeth Larrick. In this episode, we’re going to talk about trial strategy versus trial tactics and how this can often get confused. So let’s straighten it out so that you can be on the right path.

Here’s the thing, trial lawyers mix up often and frequently, and it’s not really our fault. We’re constantly bombarded with new CLEs, new tactics, a new book, and here’s the thing. We get these things mixed up because there are lots of new fangled tactics that are thrown out often at new CLEs or away somebody did their trial. We try to pick all these things up.

and put them together, which can cause some disorganization of our presentation. And that’s how we can end up losing cases. I’ve seen it in focus groups, I’ve seen it in the courtroom. And I can immediately tell when people are throwing any kind of tactic against the wall without an overarching strategy. So it gets backwards. And of course it confuses your audience, whether that’s a jury or a judge.

So today we’re gonna talk about the differences between trial strategy and trial tactics. Not just what they are, because I think most of us understand what they are, but when you need them, how they work together, and what happens when you get them backwards. I promise you your focus groups will reveal confusion faster than anything else, but you may be missing that this is a tadic

versus strategy problem versus other kind of problems with confusion. So we’ll talk about that as well. So let’s dive in to the very first point, which is strategy sets direction and tactics executed. Tactics gets you there. So the simplest way I’ve found to understand or make clear

Elizabeth Larrick (02:16.898)
what trial strategy is versus tactics is I like to think of strategy as your destination. Strategy is our 30,000 foot view of where we need to get. And then your tactics are the very specific little pieces that get you there, right? So the little jumps here and there that can ultimately get you to your overarching destination. So again, strategy is your

big picture, our overarching theme, right? Our story that we are trying to tell, our two to three very critical points that the jury needs to come down on our side in order to get the V. But tactics are really about that specific cross-exam question, right? The metaphors that you’re using in opening statement, the very specific visual aids, and even down to the colors that you’re using, right? Those are tactics.

So let’s talk about a very common trial strategy that I hear, but is also very challenging to actually prove, which is part of the thing. If you’re gonna choose the strategy of corporate greed, right? Profits over people, profits over safety. That’s a total strategy and this is your destination, right? This is where you want the jury to be ending up and thinking. However, it’s our tactics that get us there to be able to

So again, thinking through our corporate documents, our discussions you may have in deposition, right? And then how you’re putting that together for visuals, how you’re putting that together for cross exam, what’s the order of witnesses that gets you to that ultimate destination of corporate greed, profits over safety. Your strategy is really kind of an overarching why. Now I have seen,

organization tactics that are helpful for memory, that are helpful for getting people ultimately to the jury to the verdict that you want. If we’re thinking about those kinds of things, that’s like when we’re having an organizational way, like the ABCs or one, two, threes presentation that goes through in a way where your memory is going to pick it up.

Elizabeth Larrick (04:41.72)
Those are very helpful things, but those can also end up just being tactics for just throwing several different things and not, again, having this overarching strategy. Let me give you an example. So if your trial strategy is to show the jury, the company, the defendant knew about the danger but did nothing, right? That’s our overarching strategy. Now we’re gonna look at our tactics. So.

who’s gonna be our first witness? Well, that would be a company, corporate representative, or maybe it’s the safety director. And then it’s the very specific documents that you’re going to use in the order of those documents. Again, the order of cross exam, the style, the questions of cross exam. Each of those tactics is gonna serve your strategy. And so here’s the thing, you can have a lot of tactics without strategy,

and it’s going to leave jurors not putting the whole thing together. Many times we try to lead the horse to water and hopefully they’ll drink, but you’ve got to actually put it all together for them with our trial strategy. So I’ve definitely seen focus groups where there are lots of great tactics with, we’ve got opening statements and maybe some videos of cross-exam, but without

the full direction of you giving that strategy, then generally jurors are pretty well lost. So we wanna make sure that we had these two things together. So let’s talk about then point number two, which is when do we think about these things and when do we start planning for them? Now, most of the time we wanna be thinking about strategy from the very beginning, even with our basic bone facts.

we can be thinking about our strategy because most of the time our tactics can’t really be formulated until we’re getting into that trial prep phase. So our strategy comes early thinking in discovery so that we know the documents that we’re aiming for to prove that they put safety over people. We’re looking for those documents that show that they

Elizabeth Larrick (07:05.154)
chose to ignore the danger or made a different decision, maybe that was cheaper. Those are the things we wanna be looking and thinking about discovery, our depositions, questions. Those are things that are really gonna feed into our overall strategy. And a great thing you can do is focus group early to see if your working strategy is working. So, and we talk about this often on the podcast.

but using focus groups early to make sure that we’re making good strategic choices. Don’t forget, that is something that I can help you with. If you are curious about how to test your strategy early in a case, you can book a free call with me. The link will be in the show notes. What we want to be doing in these early focus groups is just making sure the theme is resonating, right? Or a lot of times what I work with lawyers on is

This is my theme, I feel really good about it, but what is it missing? And when we do focus groups early enough and you get the feedback back from focus groups, you can actually go get it, right? Maybe it’s more documents, maybe it’s another witness. Sometimes it’s an expert, not always, most of the time they would rather see a document or a different witness versus an expert, but sometimes we have a lack of education.

and you need that education to make your theme work. So always be keeping that in mind if you’re missing an education piece there. So then after you do your focus groups, then you can really look at what worked, what didn’t work, what fell flat, how do we unconfuse people about this? And of course your tactics will come later because once you’ve made it through discovery, you’ve made it through that final mediation, now you have a good grasp on all your evidence.

You know what your theme is, so now it’s about how do you pick the best tactics to put that theme in, but also knowing tactics can change in trial. Witnesses who don’t cooperate, right, how do you then use a different tactic to get what you need to meet that theme? And that’s why tactics are flexible, they’re adaptive, there are many different ones, like I talked about, there’s lots of different ideas. You can do the David Ball opening, can do Sardegna-Lomade opening, right?

Elizabeth Larrick (09:23.04)
Some people think the same thing. My point is we hear a lot about tactics. There are lots to choose from, but we need to choose the right ones to meet our trial strategy. Okay, let’s move into our last point here, which is what can it cost you when you confuse the two? Or like we talked about earlier, you do it backwards. You think all about the tactics and you come up with that theme a little later.

So we talked about this just very briefly, which is you can really waste a lot of time and energy and effort on tactics and the jury never get the overarching theme. And then they’re just kind of lost. They may let you score a couple points here and there, but ultimately you’re not gonna win the game and that’s what we need. We need to win the game. So.

you can end up doing a lot of wasted time and focus groups. This is where when folks come to me and they say, well, we’re just, we need to test everything, right? So then they’re like, we want a six hour in-person focus group. And we can totally do that. But a lot of times until you skinny things down and you simplify it and you get it down to these three key points with this six key documents, all right, let’s test that. And that’s why

in almost all of my focus groups, we have extensive planning because while testing everything you maybe think is helpful, not everything comes down to how jurors make their decision, right? They can’t take in everything. It’s almost impossible for our brains. So we wanna make sure we narrow it down to those few things so that you can really have feedback and analysis on those one or two, three key points and then you know,

they stay in or they stay out. Now I can move to the next thing versus thinking, it’s all 30 things. Well, generally not. So we don’t want to waste your time in those focus groups. The other thing that can happen is, again, we talked about inconsistent case presentation. I see this sometimes, unfortunately, where we have teams of lawyers trying cases and they’re not on the same theme. And so they’re using different tactics that can somewhat

Elizabeth Larrick (11:44.642)
be a little out of alignment for jurors. The best way I’ve heard this put is from one of my mentors, Don Keenan, who would talk about doing a cross exam that’s like the McCulloch chainsaw where you just like, you just ripping that person up or it’s the paper cuts, right? So when you have a tactic of you’re just gonna rip up this person and just tear them down all the pieces and then you have somebody else that you’re doing paper cuts,

it’s a little bit out of alignment because jurors begin to expect certain things out of the lawyers when they watch it. And when things come a little bit out of sorts, it doesn’t match their expectation like, you know, it actually caused a little bit of discombobulation in their brains. You may think Elizabeth, people are humans, we are more complicated than that. We are really not. mean, at grand scheme of things, our brains like things simple. We’ve talked about that here.

And so when we do these strategies, these tactics, and we’re a little out of pace, it can be very confusing, even if it’s just that simple of a difference in cross-examination. So we wanna have consistent case presentation. Yes, of course we wanna have consistent case presentation for our strategy, but also for the jurors and the thing of what they’re expecting out of you, what they’ve seen, what they expect, okay? We don’t wanna cause people, whoa, hold on a second, right?

We wanna be meeting their expectation that we’ve set an opening which is, I’m gonna teach you, look at me, I’m gonna tell you the truth and the facts and follow me, I’m gonna tell you what’s right. You make your decision about those guys over there on that other table. All right, so we can totally get these things wrong and that is of course the real danger. If you’re just executing tactics without understanding your underlying strategy, things may fall apart and it’s hard then to put it back together.

So if witness doesn’t come across well or a piece of evidence gets excluded or the judge rules against you on something, you may be stuck. And because you’re relying on a tactic rather than your overarching strategy, you can get flustered, not know what to do. And that’s definitely not what we want to happen in the courtroom. We want you to be very clear on your trial strategy and then have tactics that you can adjust on the fly. This is where when I work with lawyers getting ready for trial,

Elizabeth Larrick (14:05.26)
we have a witness, we have plan A, B, and C, okay? Because I want you to be prepared, no matter which way they go, right? You are very comfortable, you’re calm, you have a plan for that versus making your brain come up with that plan on the fly. Because that’s what happens in the courtroom. Bullets are flying, you gotta have a couple of different tactics so to make sure you’re always gonna get your theme across. All right, so let’s do a quick,

little recap here, which would be we’ve talked about strategy is your destination and tactics are the way that you get there. Together is how we win. So we always want your trial strategy to be started early and in our discovery phase so that we can be building things along the way. Our tactics come in a little bit later when we are getting ready for trial and we’re having

Several different tactics to meet our strategy and also have a coherent presentation throughout the way. If you confuse these things and you’re just going for tactics, you’re gonna confuse your jury. They may give you a couple points, but ultimately, again, they’re not gonna give you that verdict at the end of the day. Talked about how we can use focus groups to test those things so that you know which way you’re going. And if you’re preparing for trial right now, you want to sit down and say, okay,

Number one, what is my strategy? What is my overarching theme? And then underneath that, what are the tactics I know that can get me there? All right, thank you so much for listening to Trial Lawyer Prep. Until next time, keep prepping to win.